SEC Coach of the Year: State your case


Usually only one or two candidates stand out for SEC Coach of the Year honors, but in 2012, we have three legitimate contenders for the award.

James Franklin, Vanderbilt
2012 Record: 8-4 overall, 5-3 SEC
Vanderbilt Career Record: 14-11
2012 Resume: Vanderbilt football keeps reaching new heights under James Franklin. He’s taken the school to their first-ever back-to-back bowl games, and they’ve won six games in a row for the first time since 1955. Franklin is not only changing the brand at Vandy, but he’s changing the culture with virtually the same roster he inherited back in 2010 from a team that went 2-10. Don’t look now, but the Commodores have won eight regular season games and are looking for a ninth win with a bowl game.

Will Muschamp, Florida
2012 Record: 11-1 overall, 7-1 SEC
Florida Career Record: 18-7
2012 Resume: Will Muschamp has totally transformed a soft, selfish Florida team back into a national contender in just two seasons. The Gators have the best resume of any team in college football, having beaten four top-ranked teams in Texas A&M, LSU, Florida State and South Carolina. The Gators’ offense might not be sexy, but the +17 turnover margin is, and a top five defense is the anchor for the Gators. Muschamp took over a program in shambles from Urban Meyer with talent but no discipline, and took the Gators from a 7-6 team in 2011 to 11-1 in 2012.

Kevin Sumlin, Texas A&M
2012 Record: 10-2
Texas A&M Career Record: 10-2
2012 Resume: Many thought Kevin Sumlin’s offense would not be as dynamic as it has been at Houston, but he has silenced all the critics with his flashy offense and fun coaching style. Oh, and winning 10 games with a freshman quarterback – and helping develop the likely Heisman winner – in the toughest division in all of college football isn’t so bad either. Sumlin guided his team to wins in six road games and defeated the #1 team in the country on their home turf in Alabama. The Aggies are currently third in the country in total offense, averaging 552 yards of offense and 44.8 points per game. The Aggies were 7-6 last season before Sumlin took over the reigns. What a year, and what a debut for Sumlin and the Aggies in the SEC.

Who gets your vote and why?

Photo Credit: Rob Foldy-US PRESSWIRE



You must be logged in to post a comment. Please sign in or register

  • Either of the 3 are deserving. But my vote would go to Muschamp. In his 2nd year, he’s brought a FLA team that was hurting to, most likely, grabbing a BCS At Large bid.

    Sumlin has done a great job. But he’s also got the next Heisman winner running the offence.

  • Gotta be Sumlin…not even close
    Franklin has done well but to put this year in perspective: Vandy hasn’t beaten one team with a winning record
    Muschamp has done well in his 2nd year but took over a Gator team that is a perennial sec power that hasn’t lost a step when it comes to talent
    Sumlin is in his first year at a major program that is also in its first season playing in the toughest league in the nation. And they knocked off Goliath who was hyped as being unbeatable. There should be no argument

  • I throw my vote in for Franklin.

  • Several sent me messages on Twitter and said that Hugh Freeze should have at least been on the ballot. Freeze had a wonderful season transforming his team from 2-10 to 6-6 and bowl eligible. And if he would have beaten Vanderbilt, Texas A&M or LSU, he may have just won it. Great season all around, but Muschamp, Sumlin and Franklin all had better seasons.

  • I think Sumlin and Muschamp have been equally impressive. Vanderbilt had one signature win against Tenn…but is that even signature? Tough job to decide between Sumlin and Champ.

  • Why is everyone overlooking Hugh Freeze?

  • In my opinion this award has to go to the coach that exceeded the most expectations or had the biggest mountain to climb.
    Muschamp took a job 2 years ago that came with talent and expectation. Franklin also is a second year guy that had a huge recruiting mountain to climb…and he has succeeded in being competitive but as I said didn’t beat one winning team.
    In his 1st year Freeze turned a 2-10 team into a 6-6 team who competed in every game w the same talent
    In his 1st year Sumlin took a 6-7 big 12 team to the big bad SEC and went 10-2 knocking off the biggest bully at the toughest school along the way. CASE CLOSED

Continue scrolling for more articles.