Viewers already half asleep – the primary audience of late-night TV – might have been confused when they saw No. 18 from the Denver Broncos stopping by The Tonight Show with Jimmy Fallon on Thursday night.

No, the episode was not a repeat and Fallon did not bring back Manning for a second night. This time, “Peyton Manning” was actually comedian Kristen Wiig sporting a full Broncos uniform for an amusing appearance which can be viewed below.

For more on Manning’s actual visit, from Wednesday night, check out this recap.