Let's stop calling it a playoff, it's a Invitational. The College Football Invitational. Unless there is set criteria that everyone knows and plays under it isn't a playoff. The "eye test" is not a criteria. The FCS has criteria. Basicly the FPC committee picks who they believe is the best. No real criteria like win a conference or such. Really the BCS had it right. Use computers with set criteria that everyone knows prior to the season and then play to meet the criteria. Pretty simple if you ask me. Just my 2 cents.