And everyone complained about OSU being selected in 2014 but who beat Alabama and Oregon and won the National Championship? This year Penn State beat Ohio State on a blocked punt in Happy Valley. Michigan beat Penn State. Ohio State beat Michigan. Ohio State beat Oklahoma at Oklahoma. Michigan played only 4 games away from the big house. They beat Colorado at home. Penn State also played their out of conference games at home (except for Pitt which they lost) and Temple was probably the most difficult. Head to head does not always determine the best team. If they expand to 8 teams, then 9 & 10 will complain. There will always be someone unhappy with the selection.