O'Gara: The biggest SEC takeaways from Week 2
Week 2 was “nobody is safe Saturday.”
Defending champs? Not safe. Four-touchdown favorites? Not safe. Veteran starting quarterbacks? Not safe.
It was a strange, but eventful Saturday, especially in the SEC.
Here were the biggest SEC takeaways from Week 2:
Yes, Texas is absolutely in the national championship conversation
Some wondered if Texas could go into the Big House and impose its will. Somewhere between Quinn Ewers converting seemingly every 3rd down and Michigan kicking a 52-yard field goal in the third quarter to make a 3-possession game a 3-possession game (that’s really what happened), that question should’ve been answered.
Texas is a national title contender and last year’s title-winner is not.
Both things can be true. If Texas had barely escaped, it would’ve been a different story. Instead, the Longhorns went up 3 scores at halftime and never gave Michigan any reason to believe in the second half. It wasn’t just that Ewers looked every bit like a Heisman Trophy candidate with a new-look group of pass-catchers (it’s worth noting that veteran tight end Gunnar Helm was the go-to guy), or even that the Texas offensive line held up well against the Mason Graham-led Michigan defensive front.
It was the new-look Texas defensive line completely dominating a 1-dimensional Michigan offense. The Wolverines’ 2-quarterback system was held without a touchdown for the first 58 minutes and Michigan didn’t have a run longer than 12 yards all day. Credit Alfred Collins and Co. for winning that battle up front. Any notion that Texas would regress significantly without T’Vondre Sweat and Byron Murphy was put on hold.
The only negative of Texas’ day came when Jaydon Blue hobbled to the sideline with an apparent leg injury in the first half, which would’ve been a brutal development for a team that lost 2 scholarship running backs to season-ending injuries in fall camp. Not only did Blue return to action, but he also caught a swing past and beat Michigan’s defense to the pylon.
Disaster averted, indeed. Michigan wasn’t so fortunate.
Alabama should never schedule USF
Don’t let the final score fool you. In the middle of the 4th quarter, USF decided to settle for a field goal instead of going for it on 4th-and-goal to potentially pull within 21-19 with a 2-point conversion attempt pending. That was all she wrote for the Bulls’ upset bid. Ryan Williams scored the dagger touchdown for Alabama on the subsequent drive and Alabama fans breathed a sigh of relief on Nick Saban Night.
Speaking of Saban, yes, he struggled at USF last year. Yes, the offensive line was terrible in that one. It was also a sloppy game in which the Tide experimented with non-Jalen Milroe quarterback options.
This year, you could argue that Alabama’s offensive line was equally troubling. I’m not sure you can say that Kadyn Proctor’s presence would’ve changed that. The Tide leader, Tyler Booker, attempted to fill in at left tackle. That didn’t go particularly well, which was the story for the vast majority of Alabama’s offensive night.
The Tide had 57 rushing yards entering the 4th quarter. There was zero offensive rhythm for the Tide. Jalen Milroe fumbled a snap under center on the goal line instead of a 14-13 game in the 4th quarter. On a day in which No. 5 Notre Dame lost as a 28-point favorite at home to Northern Illinois, the notion of the Tide losing as a 30-point favorite felt all too real in that moment.
That didn’t happen, but Alabama has a ways to go offensively. Otherwise, that schedule will be even less kind than USF in the last 2 years.
DJ Lagway did everything he could with his opportunity, but …
Do I expect Billy Napier to roll with Lagway if Graham Mertz is healthy? No, I don’t. Maybe I’ll eat my words on that, but all indications are that Napier believes in Mertz and while Lagway will be involved, he isn’t going to supplant the veteran as long as he’s healthy.
The good news for Lagway is that a 456-yard performance was everything Florida fans could’ve hoped for. He showed the upside that everyone has been clamoring about since he committed to Billy Napier. That throw he made to Aidan Mizell while facing pressure was every bit of the 5-star ability on display.
THROW IT ANYWAY @DerekLagway
https://t.co/hB4MreiMiV pic.twitter.com/Q9pCPQRe6D
— Florida Gators Football (@GatorsFB) September 8, 2024
FCS opponent or not, it’s hard not to be enamored with Lagway. You can bet that if Mertz falters at any point, the basements in rural Central Florida (which don’t exist) will be heard loud and clear.
Yeah, Nico Iamaleava is the real deal, but Tennessee’s defense looks the part
Iamaleava was the star of the show on Saturday night in Charlotte, and with good reason. It doesn’t seem fair that someone so talented is executing Josh Heupel’s offense. While his Week 2 showing was mostly positive, he still had a pair of turnovers that were teachable moments in a blowout win. He’s going to continue to dominate the conversation.
But how can you not be impressed with the Tennessee defense? Tim Banks’ unit didn’t allow a touchdown — the lone score was a pick-6 on one of those aforementioned Iamaleava mistakes — for the second consecutive week. The experienced Grayson McCall couldn’t find any sort of offensive rhythm with that Tennessee defensive line setting the table. Go figure that Will Brooks had a pick-6. As in, Tennessee walk-on Will Brooks.
In other words, Tennessee defensive walk-ons have more touchdowns scored than opposing offenses against the Vols. Not too shabby.
Ain’t no (offensive identity) in Oklahoma
Yikes. Lost in the shuffle of Notre Dame’s meltdown and Alabama’s near-meltdown was the fact that Oklahoma was more than a 4-touchdown favorite against Houston and it held on for dear life late. A 16-point effort against a Houston squad that allowed 27 vs. UNLV wasn’t exactly what the Sooners were hoping for after last week’s third-down issues.
We almost witnessed an all-time blunder from the Sooners’ offense in the final minute. Jackson Arnold attempted to kneel out the final seconds, but he had to run off a few extra seconds. While that happened, Houston’s defense got a hit on the Oklahoma quarterback, which set off center Josh Bates. He took his helmet off as he was being separated by his teammates, and he was flagged for unsportsmanlike conduct. That stopped the clock and gave the ball back to Houston with 29 seconds left instead of potentially running out the clock. Oklahoma survived, but it felt indicative of the confusing night that the Sooners had.
Nic Anderson was out once again, but the home-run hitting pass-catcher’s return won’t clear up all of Oklahoma’s issues. Arnold is still learning the ropes as a first-time starter and he’s doing so behind an inexperienced offensive line that can’t establish the interior run game. That’s a problem.
If Sam Pittman’s time at Arkansas ends in 2024, remember that Oklahoma State loss
Man, that was a golden opportunity blown for the Hogs coach. Brutal. As a double-digit underdog at No. 16 Oklahoma State, Pittman watched his team self-combust down the stretch. Ball security issues plagued the Hogs, as did a defense that was remarkable in shutting down Doak Walker Award winner Ollie Gordon, who didn’t have a run longer than 5 yards in the first 3 quarters.
But instead of getting a signature win to cool his hot seat, Pittman cranked up the heat with how his team folded.
It overshadowed not only the impressive day from the Arkansas run defense, but the Hogs ground attack, which held a 233-59 advantage by day’s end. It was exactly what Bobby Petrino and that offensive staff drew up. Ja’Quinden Jackson was brilliant with a 3-touchdown performance, but he dealt with cramps throughout the day.
Pittman’s decision to go for it on 4th-and-4 instead of kicking a 40-yard field goal in a tie game didn’t work out, though it didn’t help that Kyle Ramsey missed a 41-yarder earlier in the 4th quarter.
Either way, Arkansas let a winnable game slip away. Pittman’s future was going to depend on him beating teams that Arkansas wasn’t supposed to beat. That opportunity came and went in a wild, drunken game in Stillwater.
South Carolina’s defense exposed Kentucky’s offense, and it might just expose others
I knew that true freshman Dylan Stewart and the South Carolina defense showed a ton of promise against Old Dominion. That defensive line won a too-close-for-comfort opener. Whether that would continue against Kentucky’s offensive line was a fair question to ask.
By day’s end, nothing was fair about that matchup.
South Carolina had 11 (!) tackles for loss (Kentucky had 12 but that was largely overshadowed by the day that was). It wasn’t just Stewart, though he did work through a triple team to hurry Brock Vandagriff. Debo Williams lived in the backfield, Tonka Hemingway continued to be the anchor of that defensive line and Jalon Kilgore did it all from the defensive backfield.
The Kentucky offensive line looked like an FCS team playing against a vintage Alabama defensive line. Vandagriff didn’t have any time, and when he did get time, he looked so rattled that he couldn’t go through his progressions. It’s the second consecutive week that South Carolina did that to an opposing quarterback. That’s unlike anything we’ve seen from the Gamecocks in a while. We certainly haven’t seen that in the Shane Beamer era.
So now Beamer, who improved to 3-0 against Mark Stoops, will unleash that loaded defensive line against the heralded LSU offensive line next week with College GameDay in Columbia. That’s suddenly one of the more intriguing strength-on-strength matchups of SEC play.
The Gamecocks finally have a defensive front that’s not only SEC-ready, but capable of being a weekly nightmare in conference play.
So about Auburn’s Year 2 offense … woof.
I said a lot of things about Auburn entering Saturday’s matchup vs. Cal. Take a guess which thing I was on the record saying:
- A) Payton Thorne would show his year-to-year transformation vs. Cal
- B) Payton Thorne would be the SEC’s most improved player
- C) Auburn would beat Cal 35-7
- D) Auburn would go 8-4
- E) All the above
It’s “E.” It’s always “E.”
That’s an early contender for my worst preseason take. As great as Thorne looked against an FCS team in Week 1, he was equally awful in Week 2 against a “Core 4” team. Yeah, Auburn couldn’t block a soul and the injury at right tackle hurt. Still, though. Thorne was so rattled that the only guarantee by day’s end was that the game would end with him throwing a game-sealing interception.
Hugh Freeze doubled down on Thorne by not ponying up for a portal quarterback. He surrounded Thorne with more weapons and vowed to have more control over the offense after that passing game was a disaster in Year 1.
Yeah … about that. Thorne threw 4 interceptions, and it felt like more. He was lost all day after that opening drive. Thorne was so lost that on his third interception, he didn’t realize that true freshman Cam Coleman was banged up and signaled to come out. It was that kind of day.
It could be that kind of year for Freeze if he doesn’t find some answers because the ground game wasn’t much help (Jarquez Hunter had an atypical fumble while fighting for yardage). Maybe Hank Brown can be that spark for that Auburn offense. Whatever the case, it’s hard to imagine Thorne turning things around after a day that bad in Year 2 of the system.
Luther Burden III left the game, but thankfully, he was just sick
Let’s close with some good news that initially looked like bad news. Burden left the game in the first half after bulldozing his way into the end zone on a rushing score. A Mizzou spokesperson said that Burden was dealing with an illness.
The latest on Luther Burden. He was sick this week. He felt dizzy during the game. He got an IV in the locker room. Think if it was close game, he would have tried to return.
— Frank Cusumano (@Frank_Cusumano) September 8, 2024
While that’s not ideal, that still feels significantly better than any sort of lower-body injury for the All-American receiver. Mizzou needs their star to be at 100% for the meat of that SEC schedule.
Fingers crossed that Burden is at full go next week.
don’t forget that freeze completely threw his entire offensive staff under the bus after the bowl game and alluded that he had no part in the game-planning of that game, as he was focused on recruiting. he vowed to get more involved. considering recruiting, his faithful preached that he significantly upgraded the roster this past offseason, cause he’s such a good recruiter.
woof….indeed!
congrats to sc. i definitely didn’t see that performance in lex coming.
> Hugh Freeze doubled down on Thorne by not ponying up for a portal quarterback.
This was just a huge miss, flat out. We should have Cam Ward (for example.)
I am a patient Auburn fan but the “War Eagle anyway”s are becoming tiring.
Cam Ward…
talking to the sideline reporter after Miami KO”d Florida in Week 1…
“…I have never been that prepared to play a game.”
Cristobal, being a great recruiter, enticed Ward to Miami with all the other things Mario does well. Cristobal takes great pride in having a well coached offensive line…
Freeze would have had to be on top of his game to get the QB Cristobal got; Week 2 let us know Freeze wasn’t.
For what it’s worth, Cam Ward put the word out that he would transfer to the highest NIL bidder that offered him their starting job.
Auburn used up most of their NIL budget on signing that top 5 HS class LY and don’t have a billionaire sugar daddy like Miami has. So Freeze didn’t even enter into the Ward silent auction. Norvell at FSU did and came up way short. So, FSU settled for DJU and we now know how that one played out for them.
Nice job…
filling the space between the lines out…
that’s what a chat is all about!
Money was the only reason ward went to Miami…
are you sure?
No. Money was the deciding factor between Miami and FSU. He only officially visited those two schools and both offered him their starting job and showed him their plans to compete for the ACC title and a playoff run. Miami won his commitment because they put the most NIL $$$ on the table.
Nobody else seriously participated in the auction.
“his faithful preached that he significantly upgraded the roster this past offseason”
He did via recruiting. One can recruit the best players in the country but if one can’t coach….there’s a problem.
Freeze just seems like he’s not focused at all during the games. I honestly don’t think he cares and AU will suffer for it.
AU can not fire him. We’re stuck with him for 4-5 more years.
As a Mizzou fan, I am sorry to hear this. I understand far too well about coaching issues. We have not had a decent coach (until Drink) since Pinkel – he was a very hard man to replace. Some have “it” and some, just like players, simply don’t. But being stuck with one who can’t light a fire under his own players just plain sucks. I am truly sorry to hear about this.
All but your last sentence also applies to Napier at Florida. We’ll see how things play out this year, but thankfully, we’re not stuck with beyond this year.
Alabama was down two excellent O linemen and played one who was essentially a third-stringer. He was a big source of the struggles all night. Late in the fourth, when Alabama put one of the two dinged linemen in, the offense scored three TDs in what seemed like two minutes. I am not sure how much can be deduced from yesterday.
Keep that in mind when you say you are not sure how much Proctor would have helped.
I dunno, Milroe still looks baffled by reading defenses, especially presnap adjustments; he holds the ball too long and fails to get rid of the ball when the play is obviously done; and he is less accurate than last year with deep balls.
D kinda settled down, but some receivers were running wild and B Brown couldn’t hit them.
Agreed that oline woes were certainly a major reason for offensive struggles, but Milroe ultimately cannot be counted on to run a passing offense that requires being able to make good decisions and adjustments.
Good info on OL, I didn’t see the game.
The O-line struggled, but the book has been written on how to handle Milroe. Blitz, blitz, blitz. Texas and Michigan last year, USF last night.
USF brought pressure and Zero Blitz all night. O-line struggles to handle it, Milroe slow to recognize it, and play calling not helping. Biggest issue this offense needs to work on. Hopefully a fully healthy O-line will mitigate the issue.
Interesting game to watch, for sure. College football is chaos.
Interesting read. I am not saying we will roll into Bama and beat y’all (Mizzou), but if these O-Line woes continue, it should make for one helluva game. Would I have said that 2 or 3 seasons ago, NO. But this is a different Alabama and a much better Mizzou squad. I hope I can go to the game – and even if we lose, what an experience it would be seeing my team play at Saban Field! Best of luck for y’all this season :)
UK’s Oline worked about as well as wet toilet paper. Vandagriff gonna be left shaking in the fetal position after next week, if they don’t figure that out. SC definitely the most improved team in SEC from week 1 to 2… or is UK just that bad?
ARK… “They could win, if it wasn’t for losing.”
Whew, that Thorne kid was just bad…
TX looks legit. UT looks legit. I didn’t see any of the other games, besides my Dawgs’ snooze fest.
Arky snatched defeat from the jaws of victory. They had the probable B12 champs on the ropes in a road game before self-destructing.
UGA, Ole Miss, UT, uTa, Bama, Mizzou are elite teams that should be in the 12 team playoffs.
I agree that it is not Vandagriff’s fault. Mahomes would struggle behind that O line.
That’s too bad too, because it would be fun to watch Vandagriff, who plays with reckless abandon, play with what Beck plays with…
and it was easy to know that…
Stoops/Vandagriff was not going to be as formidable as…
Smart/Vandagriff could have been.
Smart has a lot ridin’ on his decision to go with Beck. If Beck doesn’t get the Georgia train to the station this year, Smart’s decision to go with Beck will be an epic fail, because Beck will have failed twice with the best team in college football on his train.
Kirby’s QB decisions go…
all the way back to when Smart chose Daniels over Bennett…
Daniels injuries forced Smart to go with Bennett, Smart didn’t pick Bennett.
Don’t get me wrong…
but with Beck sleepwalking through the Dawg’s snoozefest….
we still don’t know how good he is…
You mean his performance all last year isn’t enough to give you a good idea?
12 snoozefest games didn’t get him ready for the 13th game…
Beck lost the only game that mattered in ’23.
As I seem to recall, Beck wasn’t on the field for any of Alabama’s 27 points scored in the SECC Game. Only two QBs scored more than 27 on Alabama’s D LY. Ewers pinned 34 on them early and Heisman winning Daniels barely scored 28 on ‘em in November.
If you want to argue that Beck hasn’t shown us he’s better than those two guys, I can agree with you. Otherwise, you’re just a clueless troll.
Alabama lost to both Texas and Michigan…
Beck didn’t get ‘er done, ’nuff said!
TN might have the best front 7 in the SEC. Pair that with Nico and Heups offense and it’s gonna be a fun year on Rocky Top.
“So now Beamer, who improved to 3-0 against Mark Stoops, will unleash that loaded defensive line against the heralded LSU offensive line next week with College GameDay in Columbia. That’s suddenly one of the more intriguing strength-on-strength matchups of SEC play.”
Not so fast. “heralded LSU offensive line”? Maybe last year, but not so much this year. After 2 weeks, the LSU O-line has yet to show that it can control the line of scrimmage and open holes so the Tiger running game can materialize. The USC D-line controlled the LoS. Against FCS Nicholls St., the LSU O-line was again controlled by the D-line. The O-line has done an excellent job of protecting the QB. But by not allowing the run game to materialize, the LSU offense has become one dimensional. Going into SEC play without a run game does not paint a pretty picture for the Tigers unless immediate improvements with the line are made…like now!
If Lagway did not just play his way into a starting position Napier’s “system” is a joke. You can also look back at week 1 to see how Mertz played himself out of the starting position. Lagway earning the starting position is just basic football and no disrespect for what Mertz has done for the Gators.
Hope Lagway is working with the first team in practice this week or the end of the Napier Era is likely near.
The end of the Napier Era is likely near regardless of who starts at QB. The major problems the Gators carried into this season were along the OL and defense. Don’t let the glare of what Lagway did on Saturday fool you, the problems with those two units persist and will end up being Napier’s undoing, unless he fixes them, pronto.
I do believe we are not anywhere close to being done with chaotic Saturdays. Week 2 was just the beginning I think.
It pains me, but Texas looks legitimate. I still think we won’t know how good their win over Michigan was, however, until later in the season. I think Michigan is going to lose another 2-3 games minimum.
Tennessee looks good too, but it will take some time to know how good until they face better teams.
Bama could very well be in trouble this year.
My guess is that Stoops ends the season on a much warmer seat than he started.
If Stoops is still in his seat at year’s end…
Kentucky will have not done what should have been done sooner rather than later.
Only Saban would know how he was always able to patch his offensive line up well enough to get to the Playoff year after year, because its been years, maybe a decade, since Alabama’s offensive line hasn’t been offensive.
Which takes us to the greatest coaching feat of Saban’s career.
Saban’s offensive line let a mediocre Auburn team sack Alabama’s QB seven times in the ’21 Iron Bowl. One week later, with no other option available, Saban took that same offensive offensive line to the ’21 SEC CG….
But A Funny Thing Happened on the Way to the Forum…
in a mere seven days Saban revamped that atrocious poor porous offensive line into a juggernaut protection unit. Kirby Smart’s vaunted Georgia defense, the defense of the century, didn’t touch Saban’s QB in the ’21 SEC CG.
That was either the greatest coaching feat of Saban’s career…
or it was an awesome possum Kirby Smart ring kissin’ stand down.
Take your pick, because it was one or the other!
Texas…
Sark is their coach…
that makes them, on any given week, beatable.
Stoops yanking Vandagriff out of the game to save Vandagriffs life was the only thing Stoops could do to salvage what can be salvaged…
every wide eyed player in Stoops locker room will be questioning every move Stoops makes going forward; incompetence strangles a teams hope.