Hayes: Why an SEC vs. Big Ten Challenge would be ratings gold -- and perfect way to open the 2024 season
They agreed to this game 2 years ago, then a rare meeting between Pac-12 and SEC powers in a brand new NFL stadium.
The dynamics have quickly changed.
Now LSU and USC will kick off the 2024 season in the Las Vegas Kickoff Classic with much more on the line — and as a test run for something that could grow into much more.
How much more? Dream big, everyone.
Annual SEC vs. Big Ten season-openers — all over the 2 super-conferences.
“A broadcast bonanza,” a television industry source said. “It would reinvent and rebrand how college football kicks off the season.”
And how college football rolls into a new stage of growth.
The college football world changes in 2024 with the unveiling of the new and improved 16-team SEC and Big Ten, and the Playoff expanding to 12 teams. That translates to 9 conference games for each league, and what should annually be at least a combined 6 teams from the conferences in the Playoff.
If this year’s Playoff consisted of 12 teams, 7 from the Big Ten (4) and SEC (3) 2024 super-conference lineup would’ve made the Playoff.
That leaves only 1 untouched broadcast window remaining: the season-opener.
Instead of a steady diet of Louisiana-Monroe, Chattanooga, Youngstown State and Bowling Green, these gems could highlight the beginning of every season:
- Ohio State vs. Alabama
- Florida vs. Penn State
- Michigan vs. Texas
- Georgia vs. USC
- UCLA vs. LSU
- Oklahoma vs. Nebraska
- Michigan State vs. Tennessee
A football version of the men’s basketball midseason conference vs. conference challenge would be unlike anything seen in the world of the rarely unique nonconference game.
The intensity of Week 1 nonconference games in 2022 — LSU-FSU, Utah-Florida, Ohio State-Notre Dame — stole the show.
A Big Ten vs. SEC Challenge could produce as many as 8 games with 4 million viewers — the games television craves, and games that drive media rights deals — in 1 weekend. Start the games Thursday of Week 1, and play all the way through Monday night.
The intensity and anticipation for these SEC vs. Big Ten games — unlike bowl games where players opt out, and buy-in for each team has waned — would be pegged for months.
The 2 super-conferences would dominate the opening week like nothing has in the history of the sport.
Now, the obvious question: How does it happen?
How do you get 2 super-conferences who are clearly rivals for media rights dollars and player procurement (high school recruiting, and transfer portal) to find common ground in an effort the expand the game and reward fans — while adding 1 more significant game to the schedule?
It starts with money. The Big Ten media rights deal already is set, and the SEC is negotiating with ESPN to restructure its deal with the addition of Oklahoma and Texas.
Both media rights deals begin — you guessed it — in 2024. Could an SEC vs. Big Ten Challenge be enough to reopen both deals, and earn both conferences even more media rights cash?
I’m not going to dig down into the specifics of getting out of existing nonconference games, the number of home games each team needs, etc., because none of it matters if the money is right.
I don’t want to hear that it “can’t happen” because getting university presidents from each conference to agree on anything — much less something that includes cooperation with another conference in the 1 sport that rules athletic budgets — is nearly impossible.
Those same presidents figured out a way to play through a pandemic. Shelve the egos, and make it happen.
The Big Ten will be begin a new era next month when Kevin Warren steps down as commissioner, and moves to his new job with the NFL’s Chicago Bears. There’s an opportunity for the next commissioner to build a solid and trustworthy relationship with SEC commissioner Greg Sankey.
There’s an opportunity for the 2 super-conferences to work together and find common ground — because the future of college sports revolves around their ability to do so. Pay for play is on the horizon, NIL is an unwieldy mess, and expansion has clearly placed the Big Ten and SEC at the tip of the spear for any future decisions that dictate the fate of amateur sports.
Revenue will be the No. 1 factor moving forward, and even the addition of the 12-team Playoff in 2024 — which could fetch as much as $1.4 billion annually — may not be enough to adhere to Title IX and pay players.
University presidents are constantly looking for new revenue streams, and this particular opportunity is staring them in the face. There’s no infrastructure needed, no administration processes.
It easy, it’s doable — and it grows the sport while highlighting the 2 super-conferences. It could also lead to other intriguing forms of growth.
Think about this: No sports markets itself like the NFL. The league has every month of the year covered with some form of access to its teams: from the play on the field during the season, to the buildouts of franchises in the offseason.
Now imagine a Big Ten vs. SEC Challenge lottery every May, where the games for the upcoming season are chosen. Don’t think scheduling on the fly can’t be done (hello, pandemic).
A 2-hour scheduling show, complete with analysis and coach and player interviews, would be ratings gold. To say nothing of the potential mega games produced.
Again, think NFL marketing. There is no more bulletproof sport.
It’s not a difficult lift. The top 8 teams of each conference — based on previous year’s record — are placed in a lotto machine and chosen. The bottom 8 are, too.
The home-field advantage is simply rotated with each selection.
Every year, the same process. Rinse, repeat, generate truckloads of cash.
Dream big, everyone.
Wow, an actually decent article for once.
Anyway, it would be very interesting to say the least, that’s what I will say. And I REALLY like those choices of matchups.
Never happen. Shorty wants to retire on a high note and would never agree to risk a season opening loss to Ohio State or anyone else. Shorty prefers to play multiple games against Austin Peay, then Vanderbilt for the rest of the season.
“Don’t think scheduling on the fly can’t be done (hello, pandemic).”
The “scheduling on the fly” during pandemic is not a perfect precedent because of limited crowd attendance in 2020.
It’s a courtesy to hundreds of thousands of people who are involved with a major college football game to give plenty of time to plan the trip.
Impossible? No. But saying “hey it was done in 2020” is comparing apples to oranges.
I agree, the comparison does fall flat.
That being said the comparison to basketball is strong enough to stand on its own.
LSU plays USC in Vegas the first game in 2024, then LSU turns around like 2-3 weeks later to host UCLA in Baton Rouge in the return game. 2 shots at the BIG in one season. Amazing the date and time has already been set 18 months in advance.
I need most of those maga wing nut insurrectionist denying Tucker Carlson and Fox “NEWS” watching (despite the network lying to you) posters here to get back to work building more condos and beach/lake houses for us victorious Yankees to move into!
SEC would win most every game for sure. If UGA were to play Michigan or OSU, it would be a blowout over Michigan and a close win over OSU.
The fact that the B1G acted the way they did during the pandemic, buying into every single lie Fauci and his media allies sold and perpetuated the ideological, political split that drove the pandemic precludes the SEC from ever trusting them to commit long term to something like this.
Lucky for you recess and a cookie are just ahead. P.S. Be sure and watch out for the wayward spaceship-fired lasers when you’re on the playground.
Still wearing your mask I see. Don’t ever take it off. LMAO.
It’s a talisman to ward off evil Dawglb. Sort of like wearing a cross on a chain around one’s neck… like I do.
It’s all about one’s belief system.
You do realize politicians don’t care about anyone but themselves right? Their public servants and idiots like you praise them. They’re supposed to be working for you but in the end you’re exactly what they want you to be…brainwashed
Go virtue signal somewhere else. No one cares here, you Woke fool.
Wait.
So is he woke or is he a fool?
Those two words are synonymous. So, Corch was redundant… probably to reinforce his point.
Wow, “virtue signal and woke fool” in the same sentence no less. You’re a bright one.
THOSE 700-800 black players don’t GAF bout all that MAGA B.S and what it supposedly stands for….I suspect that almost every last one of then are woke, and proud of it…and BLM supporters to boot! They wore their masks and took their 3 doses proudly, while wearing BLM tee shirts…now keep getting down and worshipping them!
Black SEC players…
Junebaby the Demorat party has brainwashed many of the black people by making them believe the gubernment has their back. All the Dems want is their vote and if a welfare check is all takes then it’s a done deal. Meanwhile what did Obama do for the blacks? Nothing.
Why do you idiots insist on turning this into some political nonsense?
I’d rather talk about LSU @ Penn St during a white out, Mich @ BAMA, UGA @ Ohio St., MichSt.@ Tenn, or even Vandy @ Northwestern. This is what this site is for, save your political ideology for FoxNews, OANN,CNN or whatever.
Sorry but I object. There’s a new reality show called “Libs Gone Wild” and it’s playing out every day before our eyes, on the internet, TV and face to face. I don’t want to see this country turned over.
Oh give us a break Corch, you’re a fan of the ONLY SEC team that is from a blue state that voted for Brandon in the last election. The day some fool from the Stacy Abrams Woke state of georgia starts telling us politics you can bet is lib fake news!
Guys…As I understand, this site is focused on SEC football. Please take your b. s. political discourse to other sites.
Plus, this is the same B1G that screwed their “alliance” partners, remember? I
An intriguing idea. I would not be opposed to seeing something like this occur. There is a lot of competition/animosity? between the conferences. I just don’t see any downside and the $$$ would be stupid rich.
It is an intriguing idea.
” The top 8 teams of each conference — based on previous year’s record ”
Would stink for a team that lost great players from the year before.
Valid point, though the transfer portal mitigates that issue somewhat. A setup like this might also contribute to the imbalance in recruiting. The best players already tend to want to play on the best teams surrounded by all the other best players. They already want to have a chance to play for a national championship. Getting the chance to participate in this season launch event against one of the best teams from the B1G/SEC would be one more draw for those who might at least consider otherwise playing for a team without so much recent success.
That said, I’m all for it.
Great idea!
I could really get behind this. You spread that out over 3 days on Labor Day weekend and not only would that be amazing, but there would be a lot of alcohol poisoning incidents. But hey you could watch the PAC 12 on tru tv while in the waiting room
haha ^^^
It is a very interesting proposition. B1G fans have always questioned how SEC teams would fare in cold weather. It wouldn’t be cold weather in early September, but at least they would have some home games. To me, the sticking point would be the effect it would have on CFP rankings. A game like this could easily knock a team out of contention later in the year.
12-team playoffs now remember. Plenty of margin for losing an early challenge.
Why should the SEC lower itself to help the Big Ten?
I grew up in Big 10 country and lived my entire adulthood in the SEC. The Big 10 does not obsess over the SEC, at all. Not on talk radio, print, TV, nothing. The only time the Big 10 area cares about the SEC is the local NFL team during draft season.
And yet, they can’t keep our names outta their mouths everywhere else.
From the TV point of view it would be fantastic. Some schools might worry about losing that first game would eliminate them from the playoffs. My take is if you can’t win the tough ones during the season you might be fooling yourself about how you will do in the playoffs
poptiger… A great take. the fact that a two(2) loss team does not get into the Playoffs makes this SEC vs B1G weekend a non-starter. Early season games are generally like extra practices, with the exception of a few early season games played vs. worthy competition. Virtually no chance of this ever happening.
The 16 team playoff will give us a lot of great matchups so I don’t think SEC-Big10 matchups in the regular season will be needed like they were in the past.
If they just limited the number of group of 5 games to one per power 5 team then I would be happy.
As long as they aren’t neutral sight games. In your format, you just set up a 3/4 rotation. Never say never, but I doubt FOX/Murdoch and ESPN/Mouse would be able to reach an agreement on it.
Curious with respect to those proposed matchups though. Not accounting for divisions, Tennessee was the number 2 team in the Conference last season. Yet we give them a team that went 5-7 overall and was near the bottom of their division in Michigan State? Meanwhile the Gators pull Penn State? Some of the matchups seem a little out of wack. Would love for the Dawgs and USC to play though.
Nice idea, but………
Would the payoff for this proposed event be equal to or greater than the payoff for making the CFP?
If I’m an administrator, would a game like this ultimately hurt my chances of making the CFP?
If I’m a conference commissioner, would this proposed series keep me from getting two or three or four teams into the 12-team CFP field?
Again, I’d love to see this happen, but I can see why it might end up not happening.
Something like this might be harder to sell if we still had a 4-team playoff. Now that the field is up to 12, losing one game to a good team on opening day shouldn’t keep you out of the playoff field IF you also have a good team.
Imagine LSU @ Penn St during a white out, Mich @ BAMA, UGA @ Ohio St., MichSt.@ Tenn, or even Vandy @ Northwestern.
Then flip it the next season.
That’s because those growing up in the north aren’t exposed to the daily “lost cause” drumbeat from the ancestors (Maga cult) of the defeated traitorous Confederacy. Thet tends to happen when you are on the winning side of a rebellion. The IQ deprived posting on here couldn’t define “WOKE” despite the repetion of grades 3,4 and 5! BTW..Hillary is still free.
Don’t egg them on. They’re senior citizens that are triggered by anything that is unfamiliar to them. Let’s keep on the subject of football please.
But hey, the south still plays the best football and it’s not even close.
deland? Take your b. s. to another site. The language spoken here is called SEC Football.