The 10 stupidest decisions college football coaches have made in 2023
We’re all experts.
There’s no way we would have handed off instead of taking a knee, or given up a game-winning TD with 10 men on the field, or given up a TD with 13 players on the field, or gone for it on 4th-and-32 with 3 timeouts left. Or … well, you get the point.
Leave those boneheaded decisions to the men who are paid millions to know more about football than anybody else.
Halfway through the 2023 season, we’ve already seen myriad examples of unthinkably bad coaching decisions.
For brevity’s sake, we narrowed this to the worst 10 … thus far:
10. Mizzou’s delay of game vs. Kansas State … one for the record books
All’s well that ends well, right?
This game ended with a historic 61-yard field goal from Harrison Mevis to knock off then-No. 15 Kansas State.
But … what was Eli Drinkwitz thinking just before that?
Mizzou had the ball at K-State’s 39-yard line — in position for a 56-yard field goal.
Somehow, coming out of a timeout, the Tigers inexplicably took a delay of game, forcing them back 5 yards.
No thanks to his coach, Mevis made it anyway — the longest kick in SEC history.
9. Florida too many No. 3s on the field vs. Utah
Players are allowed to wear the same jersey number. They’re just not allowed to be on the field at the same time.
Oops.
Utah led Florida 7-3 midway through the 2nd quarter — the early stages of a classic opening-week offensive struggle.
On 4th-and-3, the Utes punted, but Florida was flagged for having 2 players on the field wearing No. 3.
The penalty gave Utah a first down, and the Utes went on to score a TD, stretching the margin to 14-3 in a game they won 24-11.
Does Florida win without that mistake? Impossible to say, but it clearly didn’t help.
8. The Gators weren’t done, though … 13 on the field vs. Kentucky
None of the 13 players on the field managed to keep Ray Davis out of the end zone, either, but at least all 13 had on a different number.
Florida really had 13 PLAYERS on the field and still couldn’t stop #Kentucky RB Ray Davis ? pic.twitter.com/XhO665XDHk
— Your News About National Football. (@TheNFLNewspaper) September 30, 2023
7. Colorado State coach Jay Norvell poking Prime …
Seriously, you’re going to trash talk Deion Sanders before a game?
Colorado State HC Jay Norvell criticizes Colorado's Deion Sanders for not taking off his hat and sunglasses while doing interviews ?
Saturday night might a war between both teams ?pic.twitter.com/s8jExtTd5o
— The Sporting News (@sportingnews) September 14, 2023
Norvell made it personal.
Then Prime and the Buffs went out and made it painful, rallying for a late win in double overtime.
6. Jimbo Fisher vs. Alabama …
I can’t say it any better than our former SDS colleague, Michael Bratton. Technically, Bratton lists about 4 or 5 bad decisions Jimbo Fisher made in a 6-point loss to Bama, but we’ll count it as 1 entry.
I may be dressed as a clown but the real clown is Jimbo Fisher
Full show: https://t.co/btapb2S8Mx pic.twitter.com/GNsELhYAt8
— SEC Mike (@MichaelWBratton) October 9, 2023
5. Nick Saban benching Jalen Milroe
As Norvell proved, not every bad decision is made during a game.
Saban decided after the Texas loss that it was time to look for another option at QB. The grand idea to start Tyler Buchner (and then play Ty Simpson) backfired so spectacularly in an embarrassing 17-3 win at USF that Milroe regained QB1 status without ever seeing the field in Tampa.
Saban announced the return to Milton almost as soon as the clock struck 0:00.
4. There aren’t many plays for 4th-and-32 …
Mizzou trailed LSU 42-39 with 1:15 left when Drinkwitz strangely decided to go for it on 4th-and-32 at their own 28-yard line.
The odds already were long, but the Tigers had 3 timeouts.
Football 101: Punt. Call your timeouts and get the ball back and take your chances.
Or … call the ol’ hook-and-ladder play and hope 11 defenders miss.
"You've got to play the percentages in football, and that would mean punt the ball." – Robert Griffin III, as a "4th & 10 or more: No-Go – ESPN Analytics" banner is displayed on the screen. pic.twitter.com/5yzaMJ06jt
— Awful Announcing (@awfulannouncing) October 7, 2023
Mizzou did, in fact, force a quick 3-and-out, but it got the ball back at its 5-yard line with 41 seconds left. LSU promptly picked off a pass and walked in for an easy TD.
Trade punts, and the Tigers likely would have started that final drive around the 30 — needing about 25 yards to get in Mevis’ range for a game-tying kick.
3. Jedd Fisch not going for 2 … and then not knowing he had to go for 2
Arizona fans can debate which decision was worse.
USC opened the first OT with a TD and PAT.
Arizona promptly scored a TD and had a decision: Force 2OT with a kick … or try to walk it off. (Keep in mind, Arizona tied the game in the 4th quarter with a TD and 2-point conversion.)
Jedd Fisch decided to kick and keep playing.
Arizona opened the 2nd OT and scored again. But it appeared that Fisch didn’t know the Wildcats had to go for 2. His QB was on the sideline with his helmet off. Eventually, the Cats called a timeout. Their 2-point try failed.
It’s sure looked like Arizona coach Jedd Fisch didn’t remember in moment 2pt mandated in OT2; lip reading on TV appeared that way.
Did that factor in decision to NOT go for 2 in OT1? Put another way, (1) go for the win, or (2) play game of HORSE with nation’s best player? pic.twitter.com/e65Tc58aBJ
— Brett Fera (@brettfera) October 8, 2023
USC eventually won in 3OT — long after the Cats had a chance to walk it off.
2. Notre Dame playing prevent defense on 3rd-and-19 vs. OSU
Let’s set the stage: Notre Dame led Ohio State 14-10. OSU was driving, but running out of time to score a game-winning TD.
The Irish had just blitzed OSU Kyle McCord, forcing an intentional grounding to set up 3rd-and-19 from the Notre Dame 22. Just 15 seconds remained.
The Irish were 2 plays from a signature win. Send the house again, force McCord into another rushed throw. Simple, right?
Instead, Irish head coach Marcus Freeman played it safe. He only rushed 3 and dropped 8 into coverage.
McCord calmly scanned the field and hit Emeka Egbuka for a 21-yard gain to the Irish 2-yard line.
The clock stopped with 7 seconds. OSU had time to attempt 2 passes. Both were incomplete.
Notre Dame changed personnel, somehow resulting in only 10 players being on the field for the final play. OSU ran it in for a TD.
Many focused on the final play gaffe — only 10 on the field — but the game was lost when Freeman decided to play prevent on 3rd-and-19.
1. Miami copying the ‘Miracle at the Meadowlands’ play
First of all, let the record forever show that it wasn’t actually a fumble, a’ight? Miami running back Donald Chaney’s left forearm was on the ground before Georgia Tech ripped the football loose.
Was Miami’s RB down on the critical fumble in the final minute? pic.twitter.com/cYEeRdVQXR
— CFB Kings (@CFBKings) October 8, 2023
The fact that nobody cares that that the Canes got jobbed confirms that people hate The U more than they hate bad refs, which is hysterical.
“We’re not blaming refs…Anything you want to say about Mario Cristobal, you’re certainly justified in saying it. That was terrible. He turned a win into a loss.” – @MichaelRyanRuiz
? https://t.co/LLb8Ysf2hw pic.twitter.com/UChGjOwnaA
— Dan Le Batard Show with Stugotz (@LeBatardShow) October 9, 2023
It’s also impossible to feel bad for Miami, when all the Canes had to do was handle a simple center-QB exchange, kneel down, and shake hands.
The only chance Georgia Tech had to win was if Miami did something utterly stupid, you know, like taking a page of out of the Miracle at the Meadowlands playbook.
Top 2 worst coaching mistake ever, and if u wanna put it at number one on front of this, go ahead. Miracle at the meadowlands all over again pic.twitter.com/2V7FD4seqk
— Matthew | Angry-est (@AngryBilliever) October 8, 2023
On cue, Cristobal complied.
At least The U. is No. 1 in something, right?