Friedlander: Florida State starts the season with a taste of karma ... but don't write off the 'Noles yet
The celebration began in Dublin, Ireland about the time Aidan Birr’s game-winning field split the uprights.
But the euphoria produced by Georgia Tech’s Week 0 upset of Florida State quickly spread like a tsunami from the pitch of a soccer stadium on the Emerald Isle across the Atlantic to the land in which proper football, the kind that uses an oblong ball, is normally played.
Other than those in Tallahassee, everyone has reason to be happy about the Yellow Jackets’ 24-21 victory Saturday.
And not just because it kicked off the new football season with an entertaining bang.
The haters who have spent the past 7 months trashing the ACC and telling everyone who would listen that the Seminoles had no business being in last year’s College Football Playoff didn’t have to wait long for a result to prove their point.
As for those who actually care about the ACC – you know, those associated with at least 1 of the other 16 football-playing schools – they’re smiling from ear-to-ear over the karma the Seminoles have brought upon themselves.
If you’re going to sue your conference because you think you’re too good for it and want to get out, it’s probably not a good PR move to lose your first conference game with the entire country watching.
To a team picked to finish 9th in the preseason poll.
📍𝐃𝐔𝐁lin
Aidan Birr makes a 44-yard field goal to secure @GeorgiaTechFB's win and upset over No. 10 Florida State@GeorgiaTechFB | #StingEm 🐝 | @cpisecurity pic.twitter.com/PwApBFN0nJ
— ACC Digital Network (@theACCDN) August 24, 2024
Make no mistake. The piling on FSU that’s so gleefully happening on social media as a result of Saturday’s loss is well deserved.
At the same time, though, it might be wise to bookmark it for future use if you’re one of the few, the proud, who aren’t celebrating right now.
Because as the time-worn cliché reminds us, the season is a marathon not a sprint. And at least in the numerical sense, the 2024 season doesn’t actually begin until next week.
Although there were a multitude of warning signs, including a big one that might not be fixable, it would be unwise to write the Seminoles off as an ACC and national championship contender based on this small sample size.
Let’s start with the specifics of this game.
It’s an upset you should have seen coming like a hurricane brewing in the Caribbean. The only thing missing was the forecast map with all the spaghetti-like lines on it showing us where the storm was going to hit.
The dynamic was almost identical to the one that preceded Duke’s takedown of preseason conference favorite Clemson 51 weeks ago.
Veteran team with a difference-maker at quarterback and a defense coordinated by Tyler Santucci vs. a talented brand-name opponent playing its first game with a virtually new lineup. In a non-intimidating environment to the double-digit underdog.
Throw in the fact that Tech came into the game 4-0 against ranked ACC opponents under Brent Key, with only 1 of those games at home, and you have the recipe for the Irish stew the Seminoles got served at Aviva Stadium.
Needless to say, Mike Norvell and his staff have a lot to work on between now and Monday, Sept. 2, when they try to avoid an 0-2 start in the conference against Boston College.
Their primary focus should be up front on the offensive and defensive lines. Considering all the new pieces that have to learn how to work and play together, those are the two areas Norvell figured would be the least of his worries during the early going.
But here we are.
Although the Yellow Jackets were only able to sack quarterback DJ Uiagalelei once, FSU’s offensive line had trouble keeping the Yellow Jackets out of his backfield all day. It was even more of a liability in the ground game. The Seminoles gained only 115 yards on 31 carries. And 60 of those came on the game’s opening drive.
Their opponent had no such trouble running the ball. With quarterback Haynes King and running backs Jamal Haynes and Chad Alexander taking turns doing the damage, Tech averaged better than 5 yards per carry while churning out 190 yards against Patrick Payton and a defensive line touted to be one of the nation’s best.
Welcome back to college football 😎@Jamalhaynes16 tallied two TDs while averaging 6.8 yards per carry in Ireland @GeorgiaTechFB | @GTAthletics | #StingEm 🐝 pic.twitter.com/dC0iaDPjBT
— ACC Digital Network (@theACCDN) August 24, 2024
At least those issues are fixable. The one that might not be is at the most important position on the field.
It’s a given that Uiagalelei is no Jordan Travis. If he was, he wouldn’t have been run out of Clemson. This is not to say he can’t be an effective quarterback. He’s had success, particularly last season at Oregon State.
But he is who he is.
FSU is going to have to deal with the reality that for all the precision passes he throws – like the 2 4th-down lasers that kept a key late touchdown drive alive – he’s going to have just as many if not more errant throws that sail over open receivers’ heads. Or leads them out of bounds.
"man this kid can rip it" I think to myself as DJ Uiagalalei sails a pass five yards over his receiver's head out of bounds for the fifth time today
— Matt Hinton (@MattRHinton) August 24, 2024
That’s an inconsistency the Seminoles are going to have to live with and game plan around as they negotiate their way through the next 11 games on the regular-season schedule. It’s a journey that could still lead to the top of the conference standings when all is said and done.
But it won’t be as easy as they made it look last season.
Because as Georgia Tech showed on Saturday, the ACC is better and deeper than some want to believe. Either that or the haters are right.
Either way, somebody’s going to be celebrating.
“but don’t write off the ‘Noles yet”
No, they’re done. Bye noles.
“a defensive line touted to be one of the nation’s best.” Not even close. Which football expert said that….O’Gara? Can anyone have one of those jobs, because they are not good at what they do.
Exactly…
Who is this clown loving writer? The few, the proud that are not celebrating today? And GaTech showed everyone that the ACC is kuch better and deeper?
What idiot reaches such conclusions after watching this game?
He’s an idiot that doesn’t want to admit he and his brethren in the media were WRONG about the spear chucking clowns this season. Now, of they were wrong about the clowns, what else might they be wrong about???
All of a sudden, that November gauntlet the Gators face doesn’t look so daunting.
if
It couldn’t have happened to a more deserving team
I don’t think they are done by any means, but hopefully their fans will be a bit more reserved in their comments.
Tough to start the year 0-2 setting a bowl record for futility and then turning around and losing to a team with far less talent and (allegedly) inferior coaches.
Not much to chirp about if you’re a nole, but they still play in the weakest power conference so anything is possible.
It’s been a tough year to be an FSU fan:
* Left out of CFP
* Demolished by Georgia who was swinging after the bell when they were pushed out of the CFP.
* Lost a game 1 heartbreaker to UT in the CWS.
* ACC Commissioner Jim Phillips comes out swinging and bashes FSU and Clemson who both want out of that conference.
* Lost the season opener to Georgia Tech.
You know, I saw a pic today of the College Gameday crowd and one of them had a sign with Blake Burke’s picture. “HE SWUNG!”
To top it all off, it sounds like FSU has gotten the new Joe Milton at QB.
Just glad it ain’t me for a change.
“Swinging after the bell”? I think all of those points were scored during regulation and we sat our starters for the second half. FSU’s culture, or lack thereof, under Norvell got exposed by both teams from GA
Coach Smart asked for a running clock. But because it was a Major Bowl with expensive advertising they wouldn’t do it.
i.e. the season was completed. For Georgia (and for FSU) there was no championship to be won, nothing at stake, and nothing to prove.
By “Swinging after the bell” he meant that UGA still played that game like it mattered even though they were ALSO already snubbed from the playoffs. Meanwhile the Seminoles came in throwing a temper tantrum and showed they lacked the emotional maturity and drive to deserve a playoff berth.
Is this like the 5th article on this game? Running out of Milk?
Uiagalelei has just never panned out as anything other than a mediocre QB. His completion percentage hovers right around 60%. Nothing special. His average passing yards per play is only around 7 yards. I read that in the first half his average was -0.1 per attempt. Awful! For a big guy, he doesn’t really do much damage on the ground, but can get it over the goal in a short yardage situation. FSU is not going ANYWHERE this year . . . except maybe to the Big 12.
Don’t forget they got a PI call when the ball wasn’t even thrown in the same area code.
Brett, the point about the Seminoles not belonging in the CFP was proven last year when the Bulldogs beat them infinity to negativity. Despite the but(t) whooping the Yellow Jackets put on them today Norvell will still be talking like he’s the best coach on the planet.
And Georgia would probably hang 63 on them this year too!
Um, humble pie will be hard for Norvell to digest. And, to think that this game was scheduled as an easy cupcake win.
Where was all the media optimism Georgia Tech deserved ? This is why our sports media can’t be trusted. And why we have to believe media praise is for sale.
Friedlander called it, actually.
Maybe give him some credit at least.
Here’s a homework assignment for a sportswriter. What is the total number of wins the ACC had against the SEC, Big 10 and Big 12 last year? ans. zero or close to zero. And writing that Clemson or anybody else wants out of that conference is silly, show us where any other conference wanted one of their members. Especially Florida State but Clemson would bring ? what ?, to their next association ?
I’m no fan of the ACC, but maybe you should’ve completed your own homework assignment prior to this post. They won 12 games against those conferences last year, so your argument is ridiculous.
Credit refunded, thanks for being the auditor here. Can you follow up with how many of that leagues teams had wins against the Big 10, Big 12, and SEC?
If I ever find more time to read football news, it will still be about the SEC, so if you are right, here’s one thing in life I happy to be corrected on. Hopefully no SEC star quarterback becomes a shoplifter this year or ever!
Media is media…they love to hear themselves pontificate, but all we hear is blah, blah, blah
So much for the revenge tour.