For a while now, former Vanderbilt and NFL QB Jay Cutler has been trying to solve the mystery of who (or what) has been killing his chickens in the night.

He’s set traps, set up cameras, stayed up at night in pursuit of the culprit and even offered a reward for the capture of whatever is killing the chickens.

Below, you can see some of the steps he’s had to take, which has made for some pretty entertaining content on Instagram:

Well, the mystery has now been solved! Cutler took to Instagram on Wednesday to announce that it was a raccoon that had been plaguing his chicken coop:

Case closed.