DJ Lagway is that dude, which means the Gators have a choice to make
GAINESVILLE — Did DJ Lagway really just do that?
Did he just walk into his first start in The Swamp, at a place where they have statues of 3 Heisman winning quarterbacks outside the stadium, and throw for a Florida freshman record 456 yards and 3 touchdown passes?
Did he really just make this play and throw only a few human on the planet can make — quite literally throwing Florida receiver Aidan Mizell open — when flushed from the pocket in the third quarter?
https://twitter.com/StadiumAndGale/status/1832588550262362417
You want to do the disclaimers? Sure, let’s do the disclaimers.
Yes, the opponent was FCS Samford.
Yes, Texas A&M, which visits Gainesville next week, is a whole different animal.
But as fans of the sport of football, you know special when you see it.
A fan’s life well-lived involves taking in hundreds if not thousands of games and while it can be hard to distinguish one from another at times, you remember the moments when you first saw something or someone phenomenal.
Herschel. Peyton. Tebow. Cam. Johnny Football. Bryce. Burrow.
You know it when you see it.
Greatness, whether at its zenith or the burgeoning, bubbling up from the surface kind still in infancy, just looks different.
It’s especially different at at the quarterback position, where the difference between serviceable and good and great is a magical throw here and a brilliant 3rd-down conversion there.
Which brings us back to DJ Lagway. Who cares if that was “just Samford?”
Lagway just looks different.
To say Lagway shined in his first start for Florida undersells it.
Earlier this week, I wrote that Lagway would inject enthusiasm and joy into the fan base by making his first start Saturday night in The Swamp. I reckoned one Saturday of joy would do for a program playing its one “buy game” in a season when the Gators will play potentially the most difficult schedule in the history of college football
Lagway did much more than that in Saturday’s 45-7 win.
What he did was bring a fan base from the depths of despair to the precipice of hope in one fell four quarter swoop.
18-24 (75%), 456 yard, 3 TD.
Not a bad first start, I guess. pic.twitter.com/evAbG2VYod
— Nick de la Torre (@delatorre) September 8, 2024
“That was impressive,” Florida coach Billy Napier said after the game, underselling it in the way a rural central Florida basement dweller might undersell the need for flood insurance. “It’s never too big for the guy. It’s almost like it raises his level a little bit.”
A little bit?
Here’s how much Lagway raised the explosive nature of Florida’s offense.
Prior to Saturday night, Florida quarterbacks in the Napier era had thrown just 1 70-yard pass (Anthony Richardson in 2022). DJ Lagway threw 2 of those tonight with 77- and 85-yard completions — while also throwing 36- and 41-yard touchdown passes.
Did I mention Lagway did all this while playing with a bruised shoulder that he banged up in fall camp? Lagway rarely threw in Monday and Tuesday’s practice.
I guess we’re just talkin’ practice, though. Not a game.
Speaking of practice, when Florida’s senior quarterback Graham Mertz clears concussion protocol, he’ll go back to being QB 1 at Florida, according to Napier.
“We’re going to stay the course,” Napier said of his decision to go back to Mertz as Florida’s starter. “But as we described in the beginning, we’ll have a plan for DJ every week moving forward. He brings a different element to our team and we intend to play him every week. He’ll be a part of the plan moving forward.”
He better be.
Florida’s only path to 6 or 7 wins is much more Lagway.
The warts were still on display Saturday night.
The right side of the offensive line surrendered multiple pressures to an undersized FCS front.
The defense spent a half struggling mightily on third down.
The play-calling was bland at times and bizarre at others, like when Florida ran into an 8-man front against single high coverage on 2nd-and-8 in the first half, forcing Lagway into an immediate 3rd-and-7, a tough spot for any quarterback much less a true freshman making his first start.
Lagway made the pain of all that go away.
Here’s the reality, for everyone reading who like me, feels for Graham Mertz, one of the SEC’s most accurate and efficient quarterbacks.
After Lagway’s throw to Mizell, a great friend texted me some wisdom.
“Did Napier just walk into a Kelly Bryant/Trevor Lawrence situation?”
The comparison is perfect because like Bryant, Mertz is a good quarterback. Bryant, after all, led Clemson to a College Football Playoff. Kelly Bryant didn’t do anything wrong. Trevor Lawrence was just that good.
Dabo knew it when he saw it. Someone that special just looks different.
Mertz will start the Texas A&M game, which despite it being just Week 3 feels like one of the defining moments of Florida’s season and perhaps Napier’s final inflection point.
But while Mertz will start, it’s Lagway who gives the Gators what seemed distant a week ago — hope. A spark.
After the game, Lagway was asked why he stuck with his Florida commitment after last season’s 5-7 campaign.
“Billy Napier, for one,” Lagway responded, before flashing a grin and saying, “Go Gators.”
Lagway’s faith in Napier, along with his gargantuan talent, mean the curtain isn’t yet closed on Napier’s story as head football coach at the University of Florida.
But let’s be real, shall we? The longer Napier leashes Lagway, the closer Napier gets to the axe.
What’s that saying Florida’s head coach is fond of?
Scared money don’t make money.
A good maxim to follow.
Especially when you have the most talented freshman quarterback at Florida since the last Gator quarterback to hold a Heisman.
DJ is absolutely that dude. And you can tell just walking around GVille before the game. I was not expecting that many DJ jerseys, but I saw probably 3 or 4 DJ jerseys for every one jersey of anyone else. It was incredible to watch this kid getting more and more confident during the game, and his demeanor on the sideline showed it
Ow if only we can get the schedule changed to Samford 10 more times…CFP and Heisman baby!
Sounds like DJ did well, he’s going to be a good one.
You have a good point there Humper. A&M next week won’t be anywhere as easy to carve up, even if Lagway lives up to all the hoopla he created by carving up a mediocre FCS defense.
We’ll see whether Mertz is cleared to play next week, then see how Napier decides to use DJ if Mertz starts.
CBN needs to do several things to stop the downfall. First, promote Mike P and demote Armstrong. Roberts has us tackling better but Armstrong is a liability in calling the alignment. Our defense doubts Armstrong. They will play their tails off for Mike P.
Although I haven’t seen Lagway it seems he is the real deal. He is in a position to directly influence the program and turn the momentum around. Fire Sale now, send Waites to the basketball court because he is not a football player. Crenshaw along with George can at least hold dummies in practice drills so we can get something for the NIL money. Replace them with the younger guys and let them earn their stripes because they can do no worse. But, the younger players will at least give effort.
Mizell and Hawkins are hungry so let them loose. Wilson needs other players with speed to attract the db’s responsibilities to open space for him. Hanson can be a great target for Lagway.
CBN better have the passing game going deeper and attacking outside the hashes or Elko will collapse the middle. Elko is a seriously good defensive coach and he knows Mertz can’t make outside the hash throw’s because of arm strength and O-line weakness on the right side. Put Dez Watson in the backfield and just let him stand there and that’s better than Waites blocking sunshine.
CBN has a clear path to keeping his job. He now has to deliver results. His time is limited on our sideline. We all know that Lagway is the future and if CBN thinks that the boosters are going to accept a, “wait to next year” strategy he’s mistaken or he wants to go back to coaching at a lower level.
Marsh great point about tank. Line up ew3 in the slot, badger out wide and tank and Tj on the field. Heck throw in mizell too. Go empty backfield. Speed kills, we have some fantastic young wr talent. Let DJ do his thing with the young wideouts. Badger did impress though. Even though it was fcs samford I think the speed is real.
Great insights, Marsh – good to have you back on the pages!
You know Marsh, your comments about the right side of the OL have a lot of merit. Waites and George are just painful to watch, yet Sale is sticking with them.
During fall camp, there were rumblings we had issues on the right side of the OL. There were also occasional unattributed comments that Kearny and Westphal had taken some snaps with the ones and looked good doing it. Maybe, it’s time to replace George and Waites “with the younger guys and let them earn their stripes because they can do no worse.”
There is no downside to playing the rooks. Doing the same thing over and over expecting different results is…..
Insane!!!
Kind of like the old Warsaw Pact offensive strategy and tactics, no variation, no flexibility, and no decentralized command – which is why we would have defeated them every time regardless of force imbalance. Talk about insanity – they knew that we knew it, and they still use it!
Lagway also did not throw an interception! If Napier were smart he’d start Lagway and use Mertz as the backup.
Here’s the thing about that 456 yards: Several other Gator quarterbacks have played against cupcakes in their first starts. They didn’t throw for 456 yards. The clear difference was the average depth of target. As Neil very eloquently says, this guy is different.
Graham Mertz is a great kid and a natural leader, but the idea of him starting against A&M sickens me. What is obvious (yes, even to Billy Napier) may run headlong into Billy’s monumental ego. If it’s just a “ceremonial” start for Graham, OK. And yes, DJ will get baited and make freshman mistakes against A&M, but he’s just too good not to play. Mertz is deadly accurate on short and midrange throws but he is not on deep throws, probably because he has to force and that tightens his natural throwing motion.
This is a unique opportunity to get Lagway game experience because while A&M and Kentucky are a different level than Samford, they aren’t that good. Lagway stretches the field. It’s exceedingly rare to see that kind of arm strength with both accuracy and touch. He also showed excellent pocket presence, especially on the TD pass to Mizell. And an ugly truth: The locker room saw what they saw. They’re being diplomatic to the media, but Billy will lose the team if Lagway doesn’t play. A lot.
Florida had a misdirection deep rollout to the right designed for DJ that bought time for the sorry right side of our O-line. A&M will have that on film, so hopefully, there will be some max protect to cover up for whoever plays right tackle this coming Saturday.
The running game should actually be pretty good against A&M… so long as we run to the left side. Could also be helped by the A&M safeties staying two high when/if Lagway is in the game.
The front seven looked good, even given that it was Samford. The secondary did not inspire confidence, but fortunately the next two quarterbacks they’ll face are not good and maybe we get some guys back by the time Tennessee rolls around. Weigman just isn’t that good, and Vandagriff reminds me of the same guy I watched in a high school game with Gunner Stockton on the other side: a running quarterback with limited passing ability.
Nash, why do you feel the need to come on here and use 6 paragraphs to tell everyone what they saw with their own eyes? Maybe we can get a diagnosis from doc? It seems pretty simple to me. Billy gets paid nearly $8 million to put the players on the field that give the Gators the best chance to win. If he doesn’t do that next Saturday, he should be fired immediately. The other issue is, Mertz looked like a decent QB last year and then Billy had a full year coaching him and now he looks like what we saw last week. Could the same thing happen to D.J.?
Well, for starters, many didn’t see the game because it was only streamed on ESPN+/SECNetwork+.
Second, as I’ve said on other posts, nothing is as simple as you would like it to be.
Which reminds me, how’s you chipping in on that $13 million immediate buyout payment coming along?
Making lagway worse would be the unforgivable. If that’s the case CBN has to go. But lagway isn’t Mertz. Even CBN may not be able to derail his talent. That horrible oline might and those rpos where he runs off tackle head first might.
Because first, idjet, Nash doesn’t need a diagnosis and you probably do if you’re offended by his comments about the last game and what needs to happen going forward. Secondly, and more to the point, because Nash has been on the field with actual starters and back-ups, and it doesn’t seem like you have along with the majority of us. Third, because everyone who saw the last two games did not “see” the same games. Go tell your pal Gaga if you still have angst – as much as it troubles me to put you, of all people, in the same category, it does seem appropriate at this moment.
Swamp79, I found Nash’s post informative and a good evaluation of what he sees in our team and coaches. I get that most everyone here is disappointed in the first game and horrendous effort and poor coaching. However, I suggest that Nash’s intentions are purely a desire to balance the results with the reality and a positive path forward for our team to succeed while making the fans and alumni proud.
Myself personally, I appreciate Nash’s insights, as well as other commenters’ thoughts that post actual football talk. His assessments are better than most SDS articles and worth the time to read. (Neil’s articles are ones that I do enjoy reading.) His points make sense and I hope that some of these changes are implemented, especially the one about the o-line.
Ditto!
It’s very simple (or should be): AD Stricklin marches into HC Napier’s office and states that either Lagway is QB1 now – or Napier is fired. Refusing to start DJ is admitting he does not care about winning, and no one should be a head coach that does not care about winning.
Dog-gone-it Mookie, that’s just crazy enough to work! :)
Reposting from other thread
The season is likely in the can for UF and Billy likely a goner. Why not start lagway and give the fans some excitement in each game so fan apathy doesn’t set in which the kiss of death for the program.The outcome with mertz is known. The only reason people are tuning in now is to see what lagway does. It’s also Billy’s 1 in 14 million chance to save his job ala dr strange. But of course mertz will start and take the majority of the snaps. If Billy makes it to WLOCP and pulls a Mullen and throws the freshman to the dogs (sic) to get a concussion like Mullen did with AR when the conclusion on his tenure was beyond a doubt that would be enough “for cause”. Give him the keys now while the schedule is slightly easier. Don’t keep your Ferrari in the garage coach till it’s too late like cdm did.
Les, there’s no guarantee that Mertz will clear concussion protocol early enough this week to practice and start. After all, if he doesn’t get in the practice reps, he won’t start, even if he clears by Saturday.
That may give Napier a graceful way to keep Mertz on the bench another week and give Lagway a start vs. a good SEC defense. If the kid shines again vs. A&M, then Napier will have the unpleasant job of telling Mertz he’s now QB2. If not, he can go back to Mertz vs. MSU without incurring the full wrath of Gator Nation.
I see no harm in keeping Mertz an extra week in concussion protocol for everyone’s benefit.
Very pragmatic approach STL and marsh let DJ get the practice reps with the one’s this week and let mertz ease back into his job from protocol if DJ falters Saturday. That lets mertz and CBN save face/stick to the plan while not appearing unable to adapt. Hopefully DJ never looks back though. Going to be a very interesting week and Saturday
Les, I think it’s safe to say that CBN has been given the opportunity to make his own choice. However, it’s also safe to say that CBN has been thoroughly explained the consequences of his choices. It’s entirely about results now.
Great points marsh. If DJ does start I hope CRC is calling plays. Am I imagining it or did the play calling seem less conservative and inconsistent with CBN calling the plays to open the second half in particular
Les, I think you are right. The second half was different in the play calling. Let’s hope CBN allows Calloway to dial up plays that stretch the field against the aggies. Elko is definitely a good strategist on defense and has more experience than your average 1st year coach. The good news is that Weigman isn’t that good. Let’s hope CBN makes the right call and Calloway allows Lagway to use his wheels to create throwing lanes and the safeties have to come up and defend the run.Mertz can’t do any of that.
“Billy Napier, for one.”
Dude is playing for Napier’s job. He should get the start. Billy was adamant that he picked Mertz out of the transfer portal (as opposed to only Mertz being willing to come play for him), so maybe he feels he should stick with him. Or maybe he already has assurances he’s back next year. Napier doesn’t strike me as the kind to try and play mind games with opponents by faking them out about the QB and now A&M has tape on both anyway.
Since Trask, I don’t think I have had so much fun watching a game like the one this past Saturday. I will always root for the Gators regardless, but I definitely want to see more a Lagway. I bet Spurrier loved watching him play and make those beautiful throws. :)
GFA I’m glad you brought up the HBC and what he loved. He is already on record, in a subtle sort of way (which in and of itself is remarkable for SOS as being subtle isn’t his strong suit) in trying to get Napier to play DJ. Spurrier after the Miami fiasco stated that Napier “needs to do something different”
That statement wasn’t made through the lens all of us are looking through, being the Samford game but rather through the lens of our greatest ball coach ever who produced some of our best QB’s ever. He’s watched numerous practices since DJ arrived in Hawgtown and he knows what Napier has even if Napier doesn’t. Can you imagine SOS calling plays with this kid at QB? The fun and gun would be alive and well again in the Swamp.
I’ve been a Napier apologist for the past 2 years mostly because I realized the train wreck he inherited much like Charlie Pell did when he arrived. However, I also realize that this is year 3 and discernible progress should be evident. It wasn’t evident in the first game but was in the next game largely due to DJ.
The next 2 games are winnable games with DJ playing a significant role. If Napier doesn’t realize this and we lose both games then the writing is on the wall. Napier needs to listen to SOS before it’s too late. He may think by starting Mertz he is protecting DJ from injury or his confidence by getting thrown to the lions too early. However, waiting until Mertz gets hurt again somewhere down the road and that’s pretty much a guarantee and he’s forced to play DJ when we are facing Jawja or Texas without the game time experience over the next 2 games will have much more of a disastrous impact on DJ’s development.
Salty, I think most of us rationally stood by Napier as he untangled CDM’s left over mess during the first two seasons and sorted it into something actually competitive at least on paper – and why wouldn’t we have? He had a solid pedigree, a good record, and the obvious courage to make tough, unpopular decisions. Good strategy, tradeoffs handled, talent acquired, and once assembled the tactical game-to-game decisions by the third year should logically have had the degrees of freedom to open up regardless of how difficult the schedule might be.
It’s his team now, his men, his selections for assistants …. but I’m afraid now that it’s clear that all the necessary turmoil was cloaking the fundamental coaching liabilities that were probably present all along. The crying shame of it, as you and others have pointed out, is that he has the best and most willing mentor anyone could ask for on tap anytime he wants him. If he is not using that readily available wisdom to his full advantage, I can only explain it as self-pride …. the inherent associated stubbornness of which ironically did his predecessor and the one before him in as well.
Hopefully someone will help him realize that he needs to let go of that pride/stubbornness!
Good points Salty. Man, it would be amazing to watch a Spurrier coached offense with Lagway at QB!