Nick Lachey, a former member of the band 98 Degrees, was the celebrity guest picker for Saturday’s episode of College GameDay.

The show was live from Cincinnati on Saturday morning, where the undefeated Bearcats are vying for a spot in the College Football Playoff.

Lachey is a big Cincinnati sports fan, and he seemed to know his stuff when it came to college football.

But, it doesn’t seem he was a big hit with fans of the show. As you can see below, many GameDay fans took to Twitter to troll the former boy band member after his performance:

We’ll see where the show ends up next week. Fans will be watching closely to see who the next guest picker is.