Both the Under Armour All-America game and the U.S. Army All-America Bowl have hosted more than 25 current NFL stars or former all-conference performers in the last seven years, indicating a correlation between an invite to one of these games and success at higher levels of the sport.

However, it is difficult to discern which of the two All-America games has produced better talent since 2008. As a result, Saturday Down South has ranked the 10 most accomplished alumni from each game to give its readers a few points of comparison.

Take a look at both lists and decide for yourself once and for all which All-America game creates the best path to success at the next level:

NOTABLE ALL-AMERICA GAME ALUMS

Under Armour All-America Game

10. Matt Barkley — 2009

9. Landon Collins — 2012

8. Manti Te’o — 2009

7. Robert Nkemdiche — 2013

6. Trent Richardson — 2009

5. Jameis Winston — 2012

4. Jadeveon Clowney — 2011

3. Alshon Jeffery — 2009

2. A.J. Green — 2008

1. Julio Jones — 2008

Missed the cut: Da’Quan Bowers, Janoris Jenkins, Landry Jones, Courtney Upshaw, E.J. Manuel, Dee Milliner, Luke Joeckel, Mike Dyer, Cyrus Kouandjio, Keith Marshall, Andrus Peat, Malcolm Brown, Reuben Foster, Vernon Hargreaves, Leonard Fournette, Jamal Adams, Da’Shawn Hand, Speedy Noil, Jalen Tabor, Dalvin Cook.

Breakdown: It may seem a bit redundant to list three wideouts as the top 3 alumni of the Under Armour game, but all three are deserving of their spots at the top. Jones, Green and Jeffery all earned All-SEC honors while starring in the conference, and all three have gone on to reach the Pro Bowl in the early chapters of their NFL careers. Winston, a former Heisman-winning quarterback, cracks this list, as does Barkley, a once touted quarterback prospect turned NFL backup. Nkemdiche played in the game as the nation’s No. 1 recruit, and he’s lived up to that billing at Ole Miss. Collins was one of the nation’s best safeties this season as a junior at Alabama, and Te’o received more Heisman votes than any other defensive player in the last five years. Richardson has been an absolute bust at the NFL level, but he was as explosive as any college tailback in recent memory upon leading Alabama to a national title in 2011.

U.S. Army All-America Bowl

10. Dorial Green-Beckham — 2012

9. Matt Kalil — 2008

8. A.J. McCarron — 2009

7. Odell Beckham Jr. — 2011

6. D.J. Fluker — 2009

5. Kyle Long — 2008

5. C.J. Mosley — 2010

4. Robert Quinn — 2008

3. Marcus Lattimore — 2010

2. Patrick Peterson — 2008

1. Andrew Luck — 2008

Missed the cut: Quinton Coples, Terrelle Pryor, Kyle Rudolph, Michael Floyd, Jermaine Kearse, Rahim Moore, Tyron Smith, Jonathan Bostic, Tajh Boyd, Jarvis Jones, Morgan Moses, Aaron Murray, Logan Thomas, Vontaze Burfict, Dre Kirkpatrick, A.J. McCarron, Rueben Randle, Keenan Allen, Matt Elam, Sharrif Floyd, Kelcy Quarles, Anthony Barr, Jake Matthews, Eric Reid, Robert Woods, Teddy Bridgewater, Nick O’Leary, Sammy Watkins, De’Anthony Thomas, John Theus, T.J. Yeldon, Derrick Henry, Laremy Tunsil, Ezekiel Elliot, A’Shawn Robinson, Tre’Davious White, Nick Chubb, Jalen Hurd, Kyle Allen.

Breakdown: Luck is regarded as one of the best young NFL quarterbacks of the last 15 years, and his success early in his pro career, when combined with his long list of accomplishments during his career at Stanford, makes him an easy choice for No. 1 on the list. Peterson was a lockdown corner and electrifying kick returner during his days at LSU, and he’s filled both roles in an even more dominating manner since rising to the NFL. Injuries kept Lattimore from every taking an NFL carry, but he closed his college career as one of the best tailbacks in SEC history with more than 2,600 career yards rushing and three straight double-digit-touchdown seasons. Quinn has developed into one of the best pass rushers in the NFL, and Long, Fluker and Kalil remain three of the most dependable offensive tackles in the business. Mosley leapfrogged from greatness at Alabama to more greatness in the NFL, earning a Pro Bowl bid as a rookie in 2014 while leading the Baltimore Ravens back to the playoffs. Beckham has already asserted himself as a top wideout in the NFL, and his one-handed grab against Dallas earlier this season is regarded as one of the greatest catches in league history. Green-Beckham is a curious case after playing just one full season at Mizzou, but his 883 yards and 12 touchdowns in 2013 should be enough to prove his worth at the pro level entering this April’s draft.