It’s an especially good time to have a good quarterback, and there are plenty of capable signal callers in the SEC as we near the penultimate Saturday of the regular season.
By my estimation, 3 of the 5 best quarterbacks in the SEC are still alive in the fight for a precious spot in the College Football Playoff. Two of those 3 QBs are on the bubble, so it’s time to see what they’re really made of heading into an important Saturday slate.
With that said, let’s rank each SEC quarterback, 1-16. As always, check out previous rankings below!
***
Week 2 | Week 3 | Week 4 | Week 5 | Week 6 | Week 7 | Week 8 | Week 9 | Week 10 | Week 11 |
16. AJ Swann/Parker Puckett, Mississippi State
Mississippi State’s quarterback situation is a disaster. Jeff Lebby and the Bulldogs are limping, firing drunkenly at the sky and hoping it works out for the best as they enter the penultimate week of the regular season.
AJ Swann made his way to the locker room after an inefficient start. The straw that broke the camel’s back was a sack fumble, which convinced Lebby to turn back to Parker Puckett. Auburn then ended the game on a 31-2 run — Puckett totaled just 68 yards across 10-of-14 completions to finish the game.
Those sounds you hear creeping through the background noise are Mississippi State fans begging to be put out of their misery.
Last Week: 16 (-)
15. Marcel Reed, Texas A&M
Watching Marcel Reed play football almost always puts me in a bad mood. This week was the exception, given Reed’s latest in a long line of rancid performances came against my Tennessee Volunteers, who strolled their way to a 22-7 win in College Station.
Reed not taking a sack on Saturday was one of his most impressive feats of the season. Tennessee’s defense has made most quarterbacks it had faced look worse than they actually are, and Reed actually navigated the pocket pretty well. Once he was ready to throw, however, things quickly and consistently turned sideways.
Reed cannot throw on the run, but he definitely thinks he can. The senior QB had about 5 or 6 attempts land at the feet of his open receivers and finished Saturday 9-of-22 for 71 yards and 1 interception, a throw late and over the middle that sealed the Vols’ win.
Reed has thrown more interceptions than he has touchdowns this season and his QBR ranks 105th in the nation. For those asking Mike Elko to turn to Brady Hart to finish the year, keep this stat in mind: Hart has so far attempted 4 passes against SEC defenses this season and 2 of them were intercepted. I believe Elko when he says Reed gives them the best chance to win. That’s the whole problem here!
Texas A&M is stuck and has been ever since Elko made the decision not to pursue a quality transfer in the portal. I’d be surprised to see the Aggies win another game this season.
Last Week: 16 (+1)
14. Jared Curtis, Vanderbilt
Jared Curtis has always been so tough to place.
In terms of potential, he’s probably top 5 in the conference with silly arm talent and underrated athleticism. As for right now? Well, he looks like a true freshman quarterback trying to navigate the SEC with an underwhelming supporting cast. An arm talent like Curtis just does not work with Vanderbilt‘s offensive line — he’s running from pressure before most receivers have hit their break, and he doesn’t have the athletes nor the blocking to make the quick, horizontal game work.
Sorry, Commodores. If Curtis is going to succeed, he’ll need serious financial commitment towards fixing the offensive line. I’d be surprised to see Curtis stay in Nashville.
Last Week: 12 (-2)
13. KJ Jackson, Arkansas
KJ Jackson’s outing against South Carolina was comfortably the best of his Razorbacks career. The Arkansas QB did not turn the ball over (!) and collected over 200 yards of total offense with 2 passing touchdowns on an efficient 15-of-24 passing. Most impressive, he led Arkansas to a dominant 34-6 win over a defense that has played its best football across the past month.
This is an important final stretch for Jackson. Plenty of takes out of Fayetteville seem to indicate that the Razorbacks QB is simply being put in a poor position to succeed — I definitely agree there — and that he’ll be a better QB next year with a new OC or better help from the portal.
We’ll see about that last part.
Last Week: 14 (+1)
12. George MacIntyre, Tennessee
If healthy, George MacIntyre will remain the starter for Tennessee. A lot of Faizon Brandon fans may not want to hear that, but Tennessee’s offense as currently constructed is best run through MacIntyre as the Vols prepare for a tough fight against LSU.
It’s been well established that MacIntyre is not the flashiest passer in the SEC. Crucially, though, the redshirt freshman can make throws when needed to keep defenses from simply loading the box against DeSean Bishop. Defenses have to respect his arm. MacIntyre isn’t timid and is generally good in the intermediate game — and he’s thrown a few underrated deep balls, too. I’m still not convinced Brandon is capable of letting it rip like MacIntyre has since taking over in early October.
Tennessee is a run-first offense and a damn good one at that. The Vols want to ram the ball down your throat from start to finish. As I’ve written concerning MacIntyre before and as I will no doubt write next week and the week following, MacIntyre knows his role and he’s led Tennessee this far.
Last week: 11 (-1)
11. Aaron Philo, Florida
After weeks of uncertainty, Aaron Philo has once again taken the reins of the Florida offense. Gators head coach Jon Sumrall said Monday that Philo will be starter the remainder of the season so long as he continues to play like himself.
Philo did his best Haynes King impression on Saturday against Kentucky. He rushed for a career-high 102 yards (more than he did across his entire career at Georgia Tech) with 1 rushing touchdown while finishing an efficient 16-of-24 for 119 yards through the air.
Last Week: N/A
10. Sam Leavitt, LSU
Find yourself somebody who loves you as much as Sam Leavitt loves throwing red-zone interceptions. Leavitt is up to 5 such interceptions on the year after throwing 2 red-zone INTs (3 total) in a 1-point loss to Texas on Saturday night.
Leavitt was everything I accused him of being last week against the Longhorns. The Arizona State transfer lit up the stat sheet with 244 yards and a pair of touchdown passes but couldn’t get it done when it mattered most. Arch Manning, comparatively, marched his team down the field to put the game-winning score on the board with 3 seconds remaining.
Leavitt is a good thrower of the football, but it takes so much more than that to be considered among the best of the best in the SEC. LSU has stumbled against every good opponent it has faced this season. Can Leavitt handle Neyland Stadium?
Last Week: 8 (-2)
9. Byrum Brown, Auburn
Byrum Brown has recorded a rushing touchdown in each of Auburn’s past 8 games, the first Tiger to achieve the feat since Tre Mason in 2013.
Brown was less efficient on the ground than he has been in the past, but still put up 271 yards of total offense with 4 combined touchdowns to help the Tigers achieve bowl eligibility with a 41-9 win over Mississippi State. After Saturday’s game, Brown now leads all SEC QBs in rushing yards, having surpassed LaNorris Sellers as the South Carolina QB sat out against Arkansas.
The Auburn QB has genuinely impressed over the past few weeks. Brown has been remarkably consistent as a rusher, and he’s cut way back on the turnovers that defined his first month with the Tigers.
Last Week: 10 (+1)
8. John Mateer, Oklahoma
John Mateer is obviously responding well to Jason Witten being promoted to offensive coordinator. The game has been simplified for the Sooners QB, and Oklahoma has won 2 straight as a result.
How about this for a stat? Across the entirety of FBS, Mateer is the only QB who has started each of the past 4 games and not turned the ball over even once across that span. Mateer’s last turnover was an interception thrown against Kentucky on October 17.
Last Week: 9 (+1)
7. Kenny Minchey, Kentucky
After beating Vanderbilt in late October, Kentucky head coach Will Stein called for a “November to remember.” It’s safe to say things have not gone to plan.
Some concerns I had with Kenny Minchey earlier in the season are starting to crop back up. The Wildcats’ QB doesn’t have a strong arm, and Kentucky’s offense lacks explosiveness because of it. Worryingly, Minchey appeared to get into his own head late in the game — the UK quarterback started 15-of-18 but finished with 6 straight incompletions as Kentucky went 3-and-out or turned the ball over on downs across its final 3 drives.
Last Week: 5 (-2)
6. Austin Simmons, Mizzou
Once again, a slow start plagued Austin Simmons and his Mizzou Tigers on Saturday against the No. 1 Georgia Bulldogs.
Simmons started 1-for-6 and threw an interception on his first attempt of the game. By the time he reeled it in the game was already lost — Georgia took advantage of Simmons’ INT and never looked back. The score was 21-0 before Mizzou’s offense had eclipsed 10 plays from scrimmage.
Another season at Mizzou will do wonders for Simmons, who remains an intriguing pro prospect with the most impressive arm in the conference apart from Kamario Taylor. For now, his game is just too inconsistent to be considered among the best of the best.
Last Week: 7 (+1)
5. Arch Manning, Texas
Arch Manning did not play well for 90% of Texas’s 22-21 win over LSU Saturday night. The Longhorns’ QB makes too many poor decisions and still has work to do before he can reach his potential. On top of that, he has an excellent supporting cast that helps cover up his multitude of mistakes.
Manning is top 5 for one simple reason. He has that all-important clutch gene that NFL GMs go crazy for.
Since arriving at Texas, Manning has shown an impressive capacity for mental toughness. He helped Texas finish last season 7-1 after a 3-2 start, and Texas has won 4 straight when it matters most this season. He’s come up clutch in back-to-back weeks, aiding the Longhorns to wins over Mizzou and LSU.
Last Week: 6 (+1)
4. LaNorris Sellers, South Carolina
I gave serious thought to bumping Sellers up a spot despite the South Carolina QB not playing in Week 11. That sounds backwards, but if Saturday proved anything, it’s that South Carolina is dead in the water without its star quarterback leading the Gamecocks into battle.
The Cutter Woods experience was a brutal watch, folks. Shane Beamer decided to go with Woods despite implying postgame that Sellers was indeed available. Brace yourself if you haven’t seen it already, this is one of the most head-scratching quotes I’ve ever seen from a head coach.
Beamer later confirmed that yes, Sellers was available to play. South Carolina just believed that Woods gave the Gamecocks a better chance to win. I assume that means Sellers is still dealing with his injury issues, but if that’s the case, why was he listed as available?
Either way, Beamer said Sunday that he expects Sellers to be ready to go for Week 12 against Georgia. If this means nothing to you following the mess described above, I sure don’t blame you.
Last Week: 4 (-)
3. Trinidad Chambliss, Ole Miss
Week 11 was further proof that Trinidad Chambliss is not Ole Miss’s problem. He’s not even particularly close to being the problem, in fact.
The Rebels’ QB is getting absolutely zero help from his defense and especially OC John David Baker. The Ole Miss offense was handicapped in the first half; it’s as if the Rebels were afraid to throw the football beyond the line of scrimmage until Chambliss took matters into his own hands in the 4th quarter with a vintage Chambliss touchdown drive, capped by this magnificent throw:
Chambliss did a better job of dealing with the blitz on Saturday, too. He used his legs to counteract intense Sooners pressure, scrambling for a season-high 84 yards on 11 carries.
Last Week: 3 (-)
2. Keelon Russell, Alabama
For a moment, it looked like Alabama had no choice but to bench Keelon Russell.
The redshirt freshman quarterback started Saturday’s game over Austin Mack despite the latter QB being named the starter before pregame. Fighting through injury, Russell and the Crimson Tide offense struggled to pull away from a pesky Vanderbilt squad and entered halftime leading 7-3. Russell threw a bad interception and missed receivers left and right as Crimson Tide fans called for Kalen DeBoer to give Mack a shot.
Russell was resilient, though. Following a Vanderbilt field goal, Russell responded with a 9-play, 75-yard touchdown drive that ended with a 10-yard touchdown pass to Marshall Pritchett.
Russell finished Saturday afternoon’s outing in Nashville a solid 22-for-33 for 217 yards, 3 touchdowns and 1 interception. Most of that yardage and 2 of those touchdowns were added in the second half.
Last Week: 2 (-)
1. Gunner Stockton, Georgia
If the Heisman Trophy winner were announced today, I wouldn’t pick Georgia‘s Gunner Stockton. Jeremiah Smith still exists, and he’s been my pick since August.
That said, it’s laughable that Stockton is not being seriously considered for the award through Week 11. He’s the quarterback of the best team in the country, he’s directly responsible for blowout wins over Ole Miss and Mizzou and played exceptionally well in Georgia’s win over Alabama. In other words, Stockton is playing his best football at the best possible time.
Despite this, Stockton probably wouldn’t be in New York if the season ended after Week 11 — he has the 5th best odds to win the Heisman Trophy as of Nov. 18, behind Devon Dampier, Darian Mensah and CJ Carr.
Last Week: 1 (-)

Subscribe to the Saturday Football Newsletter โ Get the latest news and updates on your team, your conference, and the college football nation straight to your inbox.
Having trouble seeing the signup form? Some privacy or ad-blocking tools can prevent it from loading. You can subscribe directly here.
Ethan Stone is a Saturday Down South News Editor and an advocate for the return of the Seattle Supersonics.