Notre Dame robbed? Fans, media blast DPI non-call at end of ND-BYU thriller
By Andrew Olson
Published:
The top-10 showdown in Provo between No. 2 Notre Dame and No. 8 BYU delivered on the hype of an ABC primetime and ESPN College GameDay showcase game. BYU’s 28-24 upset saw the Cougars jump out to an early lead only to have the Notre Dame battle back and go up 24-21. BYU retook the lead late in the 4th quarter and held on for the thrilling victory, but some people don’t like the way the final seconds were officiated as Notre Dame tried for a game-winning score on 1st down from the 8 with 5 seconds to go.
College football fans quickly took to social media to weigh in on whether defensive pass interference should have been called on the final play of the game. In the booth, ESPN’s Kirk Herbstreit raised the question of a possible hold by the defender. ESPN’s rules expert felt it was right not to call any penalty, but many fans and media members felt otherwise.
Adding insult to injury for Notre Dame, many fans are pointing out that the clock showed 1 second, but officials indicated it was the end of the game and BYU fans took to the field. Whether at the BYU 8-yard line or closer (with a defensive penalty), many feel like Marcus Freeman’s Irish deserved another shot at a game-winning touchdown. Here’s a small sample of what’s being said on X (formerly Twitter):
I hate saying this but that is DPI. Notre Dame got robbed on that finish. Should have gotten another chance. Thought the crew had a good game but you have to call that in my opinion. Game ending play. Tough flag to throw in that spot but this crew passed on it. Bad miss imo
— OfficiatingObserver17 (@RefObserver17) October 18, 2026
Thereโs a second left when the ball hits the ground. Itโs a DPI and no flag. What are we doing? https://t.co/D84ZAJIRdl
— ☘️ (@WeAreNDFans) October 18, 2026
DPI. Blatant.
— Adam Silverstein (@SilversteinAdam) October 18, 2026
I have no idea how this isn’t DPI, but BYU has defeated No. 2 Notre Dame: https://t.co/x62SqOyd2U
— Ari Meirov (@MySportsUpdate) October 18, 2026
Letโs see here the blatant DPI and the ball hitting the ground with 1 second on the clock https://t.co/YDZVhObGKC
— Sal Morrongiello (@NJSal3625) October 18, 2026
Blatant DPI on the final play of the game I get not wanting to decide the game with the refs, but come on https://t.co/YS7wLkSa77
— J.P. Hasson (@SonofHas) October 18, 2026
I hate refs changing games but thatโs DPI
— JP Finlay (@JPFinlayNBCS) October 18, 2026
Just clearly DPI but Notre Dame did not deserve to win one bit https://t.co/optXqn9HAU
— Griffin (@Griffin_BFTV) October 18, 2026
Two angles showing clearly one second on the clock. Missed DPI and ND still shouldโve had a second play from scrimmage. Hate to say it but they got hosed #NDvsBYU #CFB2026 #CFBPlayoff https://t.co/1rvaWqJLJ1
— Blake Carter (@BlakeCarter078) October 18, 2026
Like our coverage? Make SDS a preferred source in your searches!
Andrew writes about sports to fund his love of live music and collection of concert posters. He strongly endorses the Hall of Fame campaign of Fred Taylor.



