Skip to content
DeSean Bishop, Tennessee.

SEC Football

The List: Ranking the top 10 players in the SEC through Week 12

Neil Blackmon

By Neil Blackmon

Published:


presented by toyota

We used to call the week prior to the feast of rivalry games served up every Thanksgiving โ€œCupcake Week.โ€

Prior to the pressure cooker of rivalry weekend, and having powered through the rigors of an SEC schedule, SEC teams took a moment to breathe, gobbling up the empty carbs of a sun-soaked November Saturday against the likes of Western Carolina, Chattanooga, Furman, or any number of other sacrificial lambs looking to keep their athletic departments well-funded for another calendar year.

Thereโ€™s still some of that on tap this week.

Wofford will be walloped at Ole Miss, who will be searching for any momentum ahead of the Egg Bowl. Samford will assure Auburn has a 7-win Year 1 under Alex Golesh. And yes, Chattanooga is still letting the SEC fund its athletic department. Kalen DeBoerโ€™s team will get a feel good 9th win before welcoming Auburn to Saban Field at Bryant-Denny Stadium for the Iron Bowl next weekend.

Like everything else sacred in the sport,  โ€œCupcake Weekโ€ is no longer universal.

A 9th conference game means multiple SEC teams are still playing in conference this weekend. Tennessee and Kentucky are fighting for their College Football Playoff lives. Lane Kiffin is seeing how many games a $50 million college football roster can lose in 3 months. Mike Elko is trying to avoid going the full 2013 Will Muschamp and finishing 4-8 a year after competing in the College Football Playoff. (Note: You never want to go full 2013 Will Muschamp.)

Here at โ€œThe List,โ€ we are finally nearing resolution, but we only have a few certain answers. Trinidad Chambliss wonโ€™t be your โ€œListโ€ champion. There are just too many disappointing games on theย rรฉsumรฉย at this point to compete for a โ€œship.โ€ Ditto Jadan Baugh, who is hamstrung by a leaky offensive line but has now gone a month without a 100-yard rushing effort.

Other questions linger.

Colin Simmons is still in the hunt, but has he missed too much football? How do you evaluate Tennesseeโ€™s elite defenseโ€”a group filled with great players but no singular star? Is this the greatest year for defensive players since the we started college footballโ€™s most prestigious list in 2019? Do I actually hate your favorite player, or do they need to be better at football to make โ€œthe Listโ€? Can Eli Drinkwitz win a big game away from CoMo? Can he win a big game that isnโ€™t against Florida in CoMo? Do you smoke your turkey or do you go with the old school oven approach? Can you thaw your turkey in a hot tub or is that just a weird personal injury lawyer commercial?

We donโ€™t have all the answers at โ€œThe List.โ€ But we are fortunate to have 2 more weeks of games.

As always, Honorable Mentions are first, limited to 2 per school.

Honorable Mentions: Alabama:ย Dijon Lee Jr., CB; Keelon Russell, QB.ย Auburn: Elijah Melendez, LB; Keshaun Singleton, WR. Arkansas:ย Joker Johnson, CB; Chris Marshall, WR.ย Florida: Myles Graham, LB; Jayden Woods, Edge. Georgia:ย Earnest Greene III, OT; Raylen Wilson, LB.ย Kentucky:ย Jordan Castell, S; Willie Rodriguez, TE.ย LSU:ย Tamarcus Cooley, S; Princewill Umanmielen, Edge.ย Mississippi State: Kelley Jones, CB.ย Missouri:ย Jamal Roberts, RB; Nicholas Rodriguez, LB. Oklahoma: Isaiah Sategna III, WR/Return; David Stone, DT.ย Ole Miss:ย Antonio Kite, CB; Patrick Kutas, OG.ย South Carolina:ย Nyck Harbor, WR; LaNorris Sellers, QB. Tennessee: Arion Carter, LB; Dejuan Lane, S. Texas:ย  Arch Manning, QB; Colin Simmons, Edge.ย Texas A&M:ย Mario Craver, WR; Wilkin Formby, OG.ย Vanderbilt:ย CJ Heard, S; Bryan Longwell, LB. ย 

10. Lance Heard, OT (Kentucky)

Heard’s holding penalty, resulting in a controversially awarded safety, was the offensive tackle’s first glaring mistake of an exceptional season that will end with All-American honors.

Focus on that if you’d like, but Heard’s numbers this year speak for themselves. He’s allowed 0 sacks, 0 quarterback hits, and just 13 pressures this season on 648 snaps. The last 3 offensive linemen to allow 0 sacks or hits on 650+ snaps all were Outland Trophy finalists. It’s a mystery how Heard was not.

9. Cayden Lee, WR (Missouri)

The SEC’s reception leader with 65, Lee was held in check by Georgia (3 receptions, 44 yards on 5 targets. None of that displaces the excellence he’s shown all season, which has seen Lee also rank second in the SEC in receiving yards (879) and in the top 5 in the SEC in receiving touchdowns (5). The Georgia game was Lee’s first game this season with fewer than 5 receptions. He should get back on track against a Kentucky team that’s struggled against the pass this season, ranking 99th in passing success rate defense.

8. Xavier Gilliam, DT (Tennessee)

The Vols’ behemoth in the middle is an Outland Trophy semifinalist, the lone nominee from the SEC. Through 10 games, Gilliam leads the Vols and is fifth in the SEC with 11.5 tackles for loss to go along with 6 sacks, which also ranks fifth in the conference. His 88.1 PFF grade leads the SEC and ranks third nationally among interior defensive linemen. Gilliam has 25 pressures, which ranks 6th among defensive tackles in college football. A dominant force for the nation’s most improved defense.

7. Jelani McDonald, S (Texas)

McDonald intercepted 3 passes, the most by a Longhorns player in a single game since 1997. In a season of elite defensive performances, I don’t think any player has had that electric a game.

The senior also led the Longhorns with 11 tackles and broke up another pass in helping No. 6 Texas rally to win in Baton Rouge. LSU entered the game leading the conference in yards per game (504). The Tigers left their home field with just 366 yards, one of their lowest offensive outputs of the season. McDonald is now tied for second in the SEC in interceptions this season with 4, behind only Tennessee’s Dejuan Lane (honorable mention).

6. Jadan Baugh, RB (Florida)

The SEC leader in rushing touchdowns (15), Baugh is approaching the 1,000-yard rushing mark for the second-consecutive season. He ranks third in the SEC in yards after contact (579), per PFF, and leads the conference in missed tackles forced (45). Baugh continues to project as a first-round draft pick in a consensus of NFL mock drafts. The Gators are pushing for an 8-win season — which hasn’t happened in Gainesville since the COVID-shortened 2020 campaign. Baugh’s hard-fought 79 yards helped the Gators upset No. 11 Kentucky last weekend, the third win for Florida over a top-12 team this season. That’s more than any other team in the country.

5. Luke Metz, LB (Alabama)

Metz collected 5 tackles, including 1 for loss, in Alabama’s 21-6 win over Vanderbilt. The Crimson Tide sophomore’s breakout campaign has included a pick 6, 2 game-changing interceptions, 2 fumble recoveries, and 73 tackles, which ranks second on the Alabama defense. He also registered his first pass breakup of the season. Part of one of the nation’s best linebacker corps, Metz leads a defense that ranks 12th in SP+ efficiency and 14th in defensive success rate. Alabama can lock up a Playoff berth in the Iron Bowl next week.

4. Trinidad Chambliss, QB (Ole Miss)

The Ole Miss quarterback did all he could in the fourth quarter at Oklahoma, but it wasn’t enough to offset a poor first 3 quarters and save the Rebels’ flickering Playoff hopes. Chambliss was the entire Ole Miss offense, rushing for 84 yards, largely on broken plays, and throwing for 127 yards and this strike of a touchdown to Deuce Alexander to keep Ole Miss hopes alive.

Somehow, John David Baker has not let Chambliss throw the ball downfield enough this season — and those constraints have contributed to a disappointing senior campaign. But he’s still the only “List” worthy SEC quarterback this year — and probably the one offensive player you’d want if the SEC held a November draft ahead of the Playoff.

3. DeSean Bishop, RB (Tennessee)

The Vols’ bellcow rushed for a hard-earned 97 yards in a rock fight 22-7 win at Texas A&M last week. The SEC’s leading rusher with 1,163 yards, Bishop also leads the conference in yards after contact and ranks third, behind Baugh and Jamal Roberts of Mizzou, in missed tackles forced. The last time a Tennessee running back threatened to win “The List”, the Vols went to the College Football Playoff. Bishop is poised to replicate the feat, depending on Saturday’s potentially season-defining tilt against LSU.

2. Rasheem Biles, LB (Texas)

Biles leads one of the nation’s best defenses in tackles with 78, and he was all over the football field in the win at LSU. Biles tied for the team lead with 11 tackles, registered 2 tackles for loss, and added a sack in the 22-21 victory.

No official word on whether Biles actually has a “football magnet” in his helmet, but he’s one of the premier linebackers in America, the unquestioned leader of a defense that ranks third in the SEC in havoc rate and second nationally in red-zone defense.

1. Chris Cole, LB (Georgia)

“The most disruptive defender in college football.”

That’s how Florida head coach Jon Sumrall described Cole, who had 6 tackles to add to his team-high 64 on Saturday in Georgia’s rout of No. 22 Missouri. Cole has earned the praise, leading Georgia in tackles, sacks (5), tackles for loss (9), and ranking second in pass breakups (3).

I’m just not sure what he can’t do — and neither are offensive coordinators, who spend a week trying to scheme around his strengths. The problem is that Cole plays alongside Raylen Wilson, forming the nation’s best linebacker duo, and making Georgia a “pick your poison” defense schematically. It’s a riddle few teams have solved, and a reason Georgia will be a College Football Playoff favorite next month.


Subscribe to the Saturday Football Newsletter โ€” Get the latest news and updates on your team, your conference, and the college football nation straight to your inbox.

Having trouble seeing the signup form? Some privacy or ad-blocking tools can prevent it from loading. You can subscribe directly here.

Neil Blackmon

Neil Blackmon covers SEC football and basketball for SaturdayDownSouth.com. An attorney, he is also a member of the Football and Basketball Writers Associations of America. He also coaches basketball.

You might also like...