When the second College Football Playoff came out on Tuesday night, the SEC standings were notable for a couple of precipitous drops.

After losing 10-0 to No. 1 Alabama, LSU dropped 11 spots to No. 24. Meanwhile, despite losing to a 4-5 Mississippi State team, Texas A&M only fell four spots to No. 8:

Fans were understandably confused, especially since the Aggies lost star QB Trevor Knight for the season in the loss to Mississippi State:

However, some fans disagree, saying LSU was punished for being overrated in last week’s poll: